- Messages
- 3,669
- Reaction score
- 3
I know a little about this subject, from my marathon experience. We have all seen thinks like "the human body is composed of X percent water" or "we can live without food for X number of days but need water on a Y timescale."
While the X and Y's in these equations are a mater of debate, the fact is water and proper hydration are essential to life. The role of hydration in DCI is just an example of how important is is to be properly hydrated.
You should not think of proper hydration as something you should do X number of days before a dive trip, but rather a lifestyle choice. As has been mentioned a simple rule of thumb is, if your urine is clear, you are properly hydrated.
What is the difference between sports drinks and water? Sports drinks contain glucose (which is important to athletes) and certain minerals, which aid in the absorption of fluids. A properly hydrated person with a normal activity level probably doesn't need sports drinks to stay hydrated. They also don't need the extra calories.
However, if you choose to ignore the fact that you should be properly hydrated at all times and want to hydrate quickly (a couple of days), or if you regularly dehydratrate your body through exercise, consumption, etc., sports drinks are a very good idea.
The biggest benefit of sports drinks is to endurance athletes. There are some very serious medical conditions that can occur if you drink too much water without the proper minerals. There have been a number of cases of marathoners getting very ill or dying because of a condition known as hypnatremia. Hypnatremia is an electrolyte imbalance caused by a significant decrease in salt levels. The most common cause is drinking too much water and expelling to much salt (i.e. through sweating.)
Endurance athletes are at a high risk of this because they are constantly loosing salt, and rarely taking in anything other than sugars (gels). If they drink only water an imbalance occurs. If they are drinking sports drinks, the drinks help to keep the electrolytes in balance.
So the question is should you go with water or sports drinks? It all depends on how you are eating. An endurance athlete doesn't stop for a nice sit down dinner with plenty of salt, so they clearly need the electrolytes. For a typical scuba vacation, a combination of a proper diet and plenty of water will probably fulfill your needs without adding useless calories.
James
P.S. I'm not a doctor. I didn't even stay at a Holiday Inn last night...
While the X and Y's in these equations are a mater of debate, the fact is water and proper hydration are essential to life. The role of hydration in DCI is just an example of how important is is to be properly hydrated.
You should not think of proper hydration as something you should do X number of days before a dive trip, but rather a lifestyle choice. As has been mentioned a simple rule of thumb is, if your urine is clear, you are properly hydrated.
What is the difference between sports drinks and water? Sports drinks contain glucose (which is important to athletes) and certain minerals, which aid in the absorption of fluids. A properly hydrated person with a normal activity level probably doesn't need sports drinks to stay hydrated. They also don't need the extra calories.
However, if you choose to ignore the fact that you should be properly hydrated at all times and want to hydrate quickly (a couple of days), or if you regularly dehydratrate your body through exercise, consumption, etc., sports drinks are a very good idea.
The biggest benefit of sports drinks is to endurance athletes. There are some very serious medical conditions that can occur if you drink too much water without the proper minerals. There have been a number of cases of marathoners getting very ill or dying because of a condition known as hypnatremia. Hypnatremia is an electrolyte imbalance caused by a significant decrease in salt levels. The most common cause is drinking too much water and expelling to much salt (i.e. through sweating.)
Endurance athletes are at a high risk of this because they are constantly loosing salt, and rarely taking in anything other than sugars (gels). If they drink only water an imbalance occurs. If they are drinking sports drinks, the drinks help to keep the electrolytes in balance.
So the question is should you go with water or sports drinks? It all depends on how you are eating. An endurance athlete doesn't stop for a nice sit down dinner with plenty of salt, so they clearly need the electrolytes. For a typical scuba vacation, a combination of a proper diet and plenty of water will probably fulfill your needs without adding useless calories.
James
P.S. I'm not a doctor. I didn't even stay at a Holiday Inn last night...