TheNitroxinator
Contributor
I'm in the carry-on camp. The main reason is that, at a resort, I could rent suitable replacement gear until my checked bag is found and shows up. I don't know of any resorts that would rent a suitable replacement for my camera. If I have my camera and housing with me as a carry-on, the only way its going to get lost is if the plane goes down, which will mean I have a bigger problem than lost luggage. This also covers the unlikely event of theft; you can insure yourself and get replacements for any of your gear, but if you're at the resort itself, you can rent scuba gear pretty readily. I doubt you can rent a high quality camera.
I've been using a duffel bag as my carry on. That goes in the overhead bin, and I have a laptop case as my additional carry-on that goes under my seat. I'll put a big aluminum case (a Patima case for the C5050), Nikonos 105 strobe, WAL, Macro lens, and whatever else will fit after that. I'm changing over to something with roller wheels for my next trip, I'm not sure what just yet, hopefully something I can fit the camera gear and regulator.
I've been using a duffel bag as my carry on. That goes in the overhead bin, and I have a laptop case as my additional carry-on that goes under my seat. I'll put a big aluminum case (a Patima case for the C5050), Nikonos 105 strobe, WAL, Macro lens, and whatever else will fit after that. I'm changing over to something with roller wheels for my next trip, I'm not sure what just yet, hopefully something I can fit the camera gear and regulator.