Wow... thanks for all the good feedback. It sounds like its a toss up between Mike's and Glen Ayr. We'll prob go with Mike's since its so close to the water.
I think you will like this the best - especially for the non-divers, as they will be able to go down to the beach and splash around, walk out onto the dock (bring fishing poles - someone caught an octopus there last year), and Mike rents little boats and crab rings as well.
Have fun.
DrDaddy