UPDATE: I have arranged a meeting with the GM of Secrets and several dive shop owners for next week (although it looks as if it will be postponed for the following week). The $2 fee is not the issue for us as operators because we can pass it on the the divers. BUT it is an issue that guests of the hotel, paying a premium to stay there cannot use the pier for complimentary access to board their operator of choice. The hoops we as operators have to jump through to provide a service that is a courtesy to guests there is the second issue.
Our objective is to "fight" for the hotel guests. We have also requested that they present a valid and legal copy of the pier concession agreement they have. Piers are federally zoned property and the only way to gain exclusive usage rights is to have a concession agreement, which are extremely hard to get. If the fee is eliminated for guests, we won't even have to address the jumping through hoops issue.
Dave (Aldora) - I sent you an email (and a text message to Memo) inviting you to the meeting - we hope you can join us. You have a strong voice and your's or Memo's presence would be appreciated. The more united we show them we are, the more power we will have. If we give in to this, other hotels may start following suit and this will be a never ending battle as well as huge stain on our Tourism friendly island.
I also sent Steve (3P's) a message to invite him.
I suspect that guests of Reef Residencias will still be assessed the $2 charge, but the owner of the rental units will be responsible for providing thoe to their guests. I can actually understand that they do not want non-guests having free access to their pier.
To put things in perspective; You as a guest of an all-inclusive hotel are paying for all-you can eat food, alcohol, shows, activities, the pool, towels, maid service, etc. regardless of whether you enjoy these amenities or not or how much you use them. Some people will use all of the amenities, others will use none and then there is everything in between. These things are costs of doing business for the AI and are as such built into their pricing structure for the guests. The pier is absolutely no different. If you are going to be an oceanfront AI resort on an island whose primary draw are the crystal blue waters and watersports activities ranging from ocean swimming, kayaking, to snorkeling, fishing and scuba diving - then the pier and maintenance of such is just like any other amenity and should be treated as such. Funds for maintenance can easily be allocated and also built into the pricing structure and operating budget - it is not rocket science.