I had good warmth with gauntlet-type 7mm neoprene three-finger mitts that had a cinch-strap at the wrist.
What really helped was wearing homemade wristbands of 7mm neoprene under those mitts. I made the bands from some old mitts, but you could use 2-inch wide neoprene and sew or glue the ends together.
The wristbands kept the wrist itself warmer (where the arteries are close to the surface) and also improved the seal at the wrist while reducing the constricting effect of the cinch strap.
Filling the mitts with warm water prior to donning also helped.
These measures might give you an hour of relative comfort in 43 degree water. After that, once the cold takes over, the blood vessels begin constricting and the coldness accelerates quickly. I found I could go from good dexterity and comfort at one hour to significant numbness 15 minutes later.
If you can accomplish a good seal at the wrist with minimal constriction, you'll do pretty well. So, unless you can find a mitt with a perfect fit and seal at the wrist, you'll probably be better off using a pretty loosely fitting gauntlet mitt with a cinch-strap and then filling the void with the wristbands.
Reduced circulation is a big factor. That's why holding an object can make that hand go cold quickly, as people have mentioned.
If you get mitts or gloves that constrict, especially when bending the fingers, your hands will get cold more quickly. Loose-fitting mitts with a good seal at the wrist seemed to work best for me.... when I dove wet....
Of course, drygloves have been heaven....
Dave C
What really helped was wearing homemade wristbands of 7mm neoprene under those mitts. I made the bands from some old mitts, but you could use 2-inch wide neoprene and sew or glue the ends together.
The wristbands kept the wrist itself warmer (where the arteries are close to the surface) and also improved the seal at the wrist while reducing the constricting effect of the cinch strap.
Filling the mitts with warm water prior to donning also helped.
These measures might give you an hour of relative comfort in 43 degree water. After that, once the cold takes over, the blood vessels begin constricting and the coldness accelerates quickly. I found I could go from good dexterity and comfort at one hour to significant numbness 15 minutes later.
If you can accomplish a good seal at the wrist with minimal constriction, you'll do pretty well. So, unless you can find a mitt with a perfect fit and seal at the wrist, you'll probably be better off using a pretty loosely fitting gauntlet mitt with a cinch-strap and then filling the void with the wristbands.
Reduced circulation is a big factor. That's why holding an object can make that hand go cold quickly, as people have mentioned.
If you get mitts or gloves that constrict, especially when bending the fingers, your hands will get cold more quickly. Loose-fitting mitts with a good seal at the wrist seemed to work best for me.... when I dove wet....
Of course, drygloves have been heaven....
Dave C