I'm funny that way, but I don't think $12 is too much to extend my dive time or reduce my DCS risk (since it can't be both), especially given my advancing age etc. But different strokes for different folks. And so, to answer your implied question, oJust got Nitrox certified for my upcoming 3 week trip. Been using the same shop that picks up at Residencias Reef for the past 8 years and have been mostly happy with them but now since I have my own equipment this is no longer a consideration. They charge $12 a tank for Nitrox and when diving at least 15 - 2 tank days it adds up quickly.
Just looking for some other options beside researching all the Cozumel dive shops
ne option would be to dive nitrox only on your second tank.