Chavodel8en
Contributor
I was in Cancun & PdC in December. I prefer PdC to hang out, go to restaurants, etc. Just has a nicer vibe. Even though its grown so much since I last went 20 years ago, it retains a "beach town" feel in some areas. Also, its more walkable.
Cancun feels too touristy. Yes I realize PdC is also touristy & crowded, but Cancun feels really touristy.
It also depends on what you want to do. Both Cancun & PdC have nice beaches.
If you want to take tours to Tulum, Coba & cenotes, PdC is closer. You can do the tours from Cancun, but would add 45 min. Chichen Itza is a bit closer to Cancun.
However, it sounds like you want to chill & hang out, in which case, I prefer PdC.
Edit - see that you had ruled out Cancun. I cant comment on Cozumel, as I haven't been in years.
Cancun feels too touristy. Yes I realize PdC is also touristy & crowded, but Cancun feels really touristy.
It also depends on what you want to do. Both Cancun & PdC have nice beaches.
If you want to take tours to Tulum, Coba & cenotes, PdC is closer. You can do the tours from Cancun, but would add 45 min. Chichen Itza is a bit closer to Cancun.
However, it sounds like you want to chill & hang out, in which case, I prefer PdC.
Edit - see that you had ruled out Cancun. I cant comment on Cozumel, as I haven't been in years.