Many thanks to all the great advice so far. Some background on us and a follow-up question
on weighting. We are getting in to town Sat afternoon and will definitely spend some time
talking to the folks at the dive shop where we'll be renting our rubber and weights.
For experience, I have 53 dives (just finished AOW qual. w/SSI), my wife is at 40.
I did 7 dives in the St Lawrence last summer, average temp was 65-68, wearing
farmer john bottom and L/S under armor cold gear top (no jacket) and was comfortable
even on our 3 dive day with air temps in 60's;
also done a few quarry dives with 15-20 mins <60 and one 52 min dive where a
solid 30 mins was <60 wearing the full 7mm farmer john, jacket, hood, gloves etc and
was really only noticeably chilled below 50 (but warmed up in the 85 deg sun afterwards).
My wife's coldest dive profiles are probably 30-40 mins at 74/75. she usually wears a full
3mm suit or a L/S shorty. We just got back from Cabo where several of those dives were
74/75 for most of the dive and she reported being very comfortable in a 1mm skin with
3mm L/S shorty over top. i expect this will be a bigger shock to her than to me, but i don't
think we'll have a chance to try it before the boat trip.
This brings me to my f/up question - weighting. How do we make an educated conversion
from what we're used to? I've given some examples of our setup below. for bouyancy
we both have sherwood BCD's w/integrated weight. she usually takes 2 lbs in each trim
pocket on her back.
For me:
In full gear (7mm FJ w/jacket, hood, gloves) in freshwater and a ST80 i've used 22 lbs. A bit
overweighted but no bouyancy problems. Minus the jacket and hood on AL80 16lbs was OK.
In a 3mm wetsuit + rashguard and an AL 80 in saltwater 16 lbs was ok, maybe a bit heavy.
My wife:
3mm wetsuit + rashguard and an AL 80 in saltwater her record shows 14 and 16 both working,
she took 20 in Cozumel with a 1mm skin, 3mm L/S shorty and AL80. A bit heavy on our boat
dives but it helped her on our shore dives in 15-20' with some surge.
I'm sure the guys/gals in the shop will be able to help us gauge, but if you have any general
rule(s) of thumb I'd love to hear them. We've both just completed our deep diving cert and
I understand that steel tanks give us an extra 8 to 9 lbs compared to AL (given std 80's).
thanks again.
Scott