My bet is also on the shoulder straps were/are too tight. I was stubborn to loosen mine despite seeing many suggestions to do so and finally did. It made a difference. It's really the waist strap and to a lesser extent the crotch strap that holds it securely in place. The most I have to do is once I've backrolled is give the waist strap a little additional tighten once I'm under, since the 1st tighten was done while seated on the boat.