I'm another late comer to the thread. Having not read most posts, I would have to assume you needed some serious help with some of the practical rescue exercises. Extra help for OW course students at our shop means paying an instructor for his/her extra time--perhaps even a one on one thing. I'm no expert on the Rescue Course, but would assume some sort of arrangement could've been made for that over the course of a year. Unless the instructor simply felt you needed a lot more diving before attempting Rescue again. Either way a year is a long time in limbo, and no doubt frustrating. Recommending another instructor (or even shop) was suggested, but I assume your LDS choices are about as limited in St. John's as they are here in Halifax.