Michael Schlink:
OK First of all, Christi I 'm sorry to go at you so please forgive me for what I'm about to say BUT. wscdive is right and you can't switch back to tables in most cases because of the very reason most people dive a computer ESPECIALLY on wal dives where a multi level profile is most profound. You start going up and down through Palancar caves or a few other spots and a computer will add a solid 10 minutes of bottom time, easy.
If you can afford a second computer go for it. A SUUNTO mosquito is about $300 and very nice for a backup. I won't go diving without a backup computer, ever.
As far as ALL diving being led by an instructor/divemaster and the profiles being set by them, again I'm sorry, but that's not true either. That may be the case with your op. but I can come down there any day of the week go out with several of the ops and dive when where and how long I want to. OR how 'bout the shore dive in front of La Ceiba. No DM there, Chancanab or Paradise also no DM.
Back to the post
Nice things to have
1) a big net bag to carry all your gear from the hotel to the boat
2) Floppy hat for sun protection and walking around
PS DON"T rent the little scooters for zipping around, people get run over on themPM me if you want I have quite a bit of experience in Cozumel.
Michael, Remember, he is a brand new diver. I doubt that any operator will be allowing him to go off on his own and I doubt (and discourage) that he will be doing any solo shore diving.
I agree that switching back and forth from tables to computer is a bad idea and not advisable. Undoubtedly, if he has a computer failure and has to use the tables for back-up, he will reduce his allowable bottom time. But can he safely finish the dive with his tables? Yes, most likely. This would of course depend on his profile.
Again, he is a BRAND NEW diver. I doubt that extended bottom times, deep independent dives, and solo shore dives will be an issue for him on this trip. I am not saying that you should never have a back-up computer, I'm just saying that it is not a MUST as the LDS told him. HIs question was:
The LDS said a spare computer is a must. Just wondering if I missed anything and if I really need a spare computer?
My answer remains the same. Nice to have, but not essential at this point in his diving career.
By the way, technically all boat diving within the marine park is required to be guided. If your op allows you to go off completely on your own, that is their perogative...but if something goes wrong...they will have a handful of problems to deal with. Just something to think about.
I allow a considerable amount of diver freedom based on the skill level and experience level of the divers I have at any given time. However, there is always a divemaster in the water within bubble site whether he is tooling around on his own to let the divers do their thing or if he is diving with a group of new divers that requires much more attention.
By the way, I understand where you are coming from and I agree with you for the most part. I also always have 2 computers plus a depth and pressure guage. I didn't even have a computer when I first started diving. I'm just trying to answer his question as honestly as I can based on HIS level of diving experience. If money is not an issue, then by all means...buy a back-up computer now. You may be able to make a better selection for a back-up after a little more experience however. Also, dive computers are available for rent in most shops.
I 1000% agree with you on the moped thing...PLEASE PEOPLE, DO NOT RENT MOPEDS IN COZUMEL! There are LITERALLY 3 to 5+ accidents including fatal accidents a week involving tourists on mopeds...and it's getting worse.