I'm no expert with five dry dives under my belt.
I use the suit for exposure protection, and the BC for buoyancy control. Here are a few reasons....
It's too easy to trap air in a suit, and end up upsidedown and pissed off
I've actually not been upsidedown, but I've got air in my legs that was difficult to shift to the dump.
The dump valve on the suit does NOT dump air as well as my dump on the BCD. This means that you have to be very careful ascending if using the suit as a BCD.
I'm more comfortable adding air to my BCD to control buoyancy vs. the dry suit. While this is not a huge factor, I've found that I like to add as little air to my Drysuit as possible, and in very small doses as needed. With my BCD however, I'm comfortable with adding about what I need as I decend.
As for the valve, I left it full open for the first three dives. After I became more comfortable, and was having to add air often to my suit (which uses up air) as it was dumping, I cranked down my valve to about half way. This seems to be a good spot for me, but results may vary.
There are those that use the suit as a BCD, but I'm not one of them, and I'm already becoming comfortable with how I dive the suit after a short amount of dives, so I'll likely continue with what is working for me. It will be interesting as I'm going to take a PADI drysuit class (mainly as an excuse to dive, and because I got the class for no cost) but if they force me to try and use the suit alone for buoyancy, I may fail
I'm not interested in screwing with something that is already working well for me just to attempt to prove that I can fill my suit with air :11doh: