Gotta wonder if that isn't what happened to the DM in the OP's scenario ... maybe he got interrupted at the wrong time and jumped back into his routine a step or two past where he'd left off ...
... Bob (Grateful Diver)
Dunno if that is the case or not, but I can tell you on this boat they swapped everyone's tanks but ours. I set our gear up for the first dive and they didn't even ask if I wanted them to swap tanks, as I assume they figured we would do our own since they passed right over one set of our gear. So our DM or one of the other two had swapped his tank, as it had less pressure then the previous tank.
I swapped my own tank, turned the air on to check pressure, then turned the air back off and bleed the pressure out so I wouldn't be able to breathe off the tank with the valve closed, as a routine. Tank valve is always full on or all the way off, there is never an in between...EVER! (Should I mention I forgot to turn my air on before putting my kit on? I did remember my air was off before ever trying to put my reg into my mouth though. No biggie since I can just reach back and turn the air on, which is what I did.) We all make simple mistakes, but that routine check list is what prevents the simple mistake from becoming an accident.
There were many other things that I didn't like. I never saw a complete roll call with FULL names after each dive. It was kind of hap hazard with "Oh I saw Peter", check! I walked up to the bridge to see if they had a DSC equipped radio and a GPS...NOPE! Makes my Nautilus Lifeline not work as well. Camera's and DM's? Should not happen. He spent most of the dive trying to get "the shot" so he could make a few extra bucks selling the evenings video, not paying attention to the newly certified divers, let alone us.
The best thing I heard all night was the newly certified diver complaining about using all their air without seeing the Manta Ray until the last few seconds before they HAD to go up. Then when the DM brought up going to the surface as asked he said "Yeah I probably should have listened to (Points to me) him and surfaced". I kept my mouth shut, as my concern was for my partner and myself. I was not there to baby sit anyone else, nor lecture people for not obeying a command (Thumb and clearly written note) to surface. My partner is still a new diver herself and gets my full attention. We had an interesting debrief in the car on the back to the villa. It was great to hear her say, "I sure feel better about my diving after watching those others".
The boat crew did wash everyone's gear, and offered to wash ours. I had one kit washed before they had put anything in the trash can though, with the other not far behind. Then we washed our wetsuits once back at the villa. Found the washing machine worked for rinsing gear all week as the only option, since we didn't have a bath tub.
It was also the first time I have never left a tip. The DM running out of air took away the tip.