Damselfish
Contributor
For a resorty setting the Marriott might suit you, especially if Caribbean Sea Sports moves back from the nearby Hilton. Last I read the reopening date was in September (after slipping many times over years) and they seem to mean it this time. Lions Dive is also a good place to consider. They are different in setting and atmosphere. Coral Estate might be good but is a bit of a drive to much, though not nearly as far as the west end places. Santa Barbara is probably nice but probably not where I would chose as a diver
As far as PADI vs NAUI, if you are already certified it makes no difference, those will both be accepted anywhere as well as a bunch of other agencies. (If you are planning on doing a referral and finishing your certification dives someplace else, it might be easiest to stick with the same agency - but there is a procedure for cross agency referrals so just ask the place you are thinking of diving with. Its something that’s been discussed on a number of threads here.)
As far as PADI vs NAUI, if you are already certified it makes no difference, those will both be accepted anywhere as well as a bunch of other agencies. (If you are planning on doing a referral and finishing your certification dives someplace else, it might be easiest to stick with the same agency - but there is a procedure for cross agency referrals so just ask the place you are thinking of diving with. Its something that’s been discussed on a number of threads here.)