So I finally had a chance to use this underwater the other week and I have to say that I'm very impressed. Here is a short video from one of the dives. It's unedited and not the best video (my wife is shooting and where both new to this - i was trying to get her to get closer to the fish) but it gives you a feel for the pluses and minuses of the camera:
Clown Fish - Thailand on Vimeo
The depth is probably about 45' at this point and the visibility was no more than 40' (this was shot in Thailand). It is shot in 960p (i never tried 1080 - probably should have).
Quality: As you can see the reds and purples are gone from the video (which is shame b/c the soft coral was awesome) but the yellows and some of the orange is there. There is actually no real fishbowl in this video which is nice to see - maybe b/c it was shot from a bit farther away or b/c the visibility is a bit better than in monterey. but even some other close in shots are good ( i will try to splice together a montage later)...
Use: the camera itself was very easy to use. i clipped it to my BC via one of the attached straps and let it hang (while on) during the dive. there is one button to start and stop taking video which was easy to use - i never changed the mode to take stills while underwater. Not having a screen didn't seem to pose a problem. It seems to be neutral or slightly negative as it hung during the dive.
Portability: The thing is super tiny which is great for travel - and the case is super tough so there was little fear with it rolling around in my bag.
Connection: I primarily use Linux and it connects easily as an external drive and the files play seemlessly. I tried it on Windows and easily simple. One minor quirk is that once connecting it, you have to power on, however the battery does not charge at this point - so you have to either have it charging (and not able to read the files) or file read mode and not charging - seems kind of inefficient.
Storage/Battery: I have a 32gb card for it and that seems like a good buy as you can store a crap load of video on that and not have to eat up your own hard drive. I left it on idle during both boat dives and took 30+ min of video for each dive (in ~30 sec clips for each dive) and had no problem. I then charged the battery at night. They advertise 4hrs of video and 8hrs worth for a 32gb card and i believe it.
Synopsis: I'm pretty pleased with as a dive toy. I just wanted something to capture some images underwater and it does the trick. The loss of color is sad but expected, but video is really sharp above water. the audio is pretty weak while in its case and not great out of the case but who cares for diving. All of the different straps give you some options for connecting it to your equipment.
If this a dive toy i think its a great buy. While there is nothing cute about it (as oppossed to the flip style cameras) it does the trick. If you are using this above water i may think twice and compare the audio of some of the other cameras, but for $300 i'm pretty happy!
bg