snowdog61
Contributor
Been to both, did return trips to both and could do another trip to each as I've enjoyed them enough. Can't say that about other the places in the Caribbean that I've been other than Bonaire. All were through ScubaBoard Invasions - Hotel Cozumel/Paradise Divers and Anthony's Key Resort for the trips in question. Don't think I'd have a preference though Roatan was a bit easier AFA travelling - (we did the bag drag from Cancun to save some $$) and the food was way better at AKR. Boat ride was way shorter in Roatan but Cozumel offered a little more diversity on the reefs. Honestly I don't think you'll be disappointed in either so just do them both.