merganser1:..................Stayed at Cantamar and Puesta del Sol in years past.... both are at the north end of the island and if you are diving most operators don't really like to go that far north to pick people up. You almost always have to use a cab to get to a pickup dock or to town. Suggest you try el cantil condos. www.elcantilcondos.com I think you will find them very close to town and quite excellent. Plus they are running some specials there.
A little bit biased since several of us have bought one of the El Cantil condos. There are 21 units in the first phase and 16 of the units are for rent. I will stay neutral and not disclose our unit but if you have questions on the units email me and I will be happy to answer questions.
Just returned after staying at El Cantil for a week. It was wonderful. For those who like to cook, it is convientiently located across from the Chedrai store (I don't think I spelled it correctly).
Juls