Brad_Horn
Contributor
- Messages
- 231
- Reaction score
- 68
Jon, all EN14143 aka CE certification is is a minimum threshold or sub-maximal barrier to entry to at least provide some proof that the rebreather in question meets at least the very barest minimum standard. See Gavin Anthony's DAN presentation on this pg218 https://www.diversalertnetwork.org/files/Tech_Proceedings_Feb2010.pdfthere’s no arguing that saying “work of breathing is great” without testing and data to back it up is anything other than subjective. However, having dealt with several manufacturers at the training agency level who were trying to get through the CE process, I can promise that a CE certification (at least for a rebreather) has very little to do with actual performance or safety.
There's plenty of rebreathers on the market with CE that don't have great WOB as meeting the 2.75J/L requirement isn't hard. Beating the lowest WOB option for a rebreather at 1.44J/L at 40m on air at 75lpm is a tad harder.
But then that is also just one test out of 52 odd.
However another consideration is if you have to take parts off the rebreather to get it to pass the testing does that make a mockery of the process. Quite probably. It also completely and utterly negates direct side by side comparison of the results for studies like yours; unless you know both or all systems were tested to the exact same standard ie. with BCD fitted and potentially inflated as an example.
But looking at the more esoteric element of rebreather selection you might want to consider:
The products FMECA Deep Life Design Team: Design Submission for Open Revolution
It's unmanned design validation testing Deep Life Design Team: Selected Design Validation Reports for DL & Open Safety Equipment Ltd's Rebreathers
Flood tolerance is an interesting one for you to mention as there aren't many units on the market that you can flood recover underwater from a full flood and continue on the dive.
Oh and if anyone's diving a Fathom CCR whom wants to drop its WOB in both CC and OC modes, quite happy to sell you an ALVBOV to significantly improve its actual WOB:
https://www.opensafetyglobal.com/Safety_files/DV_DL_ALVBOV_Breathing_Params_A3_100318.pdf
https://www.opensafety.eu/datasheets/ALVBOV_40m_75lpm_air_081014.pdf