wow. . . a little intimidating just reading it all!!
Question - is it a smart move to purchase this housing and try the fix? Or go for another brand? .. . there's quite a bit of markup difference though, and in past dives (before the cameras were flooded, I also bought the strobe and red filter . .. . would I need/is it recommended to get this for this housing as well?
Markup difference? Huh? I don't think it is markup, Ikelite housings are built to a higher standard and the all aluminum FIX to a yet higher standard, you get exactly what you pay for, cheap and functional, expensive and durable with greater versatility and high quality and in between.
Is it a smart move to purchase the Canon housing vs some other such as the FIX or Ikelite, that is for you to decided based on your needs and budget.
JFYI, most Canon OEM housings do not require this repair, some few seep water as described in this thread, those would require the "polishing" as per this thread.
N