Can anything be done to lessen air consumption for a beginner scuba diver?

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

Inhale to a slow count of five, exhale to a slow count of three, then repeat. SAC improves with time but I had a good SAC from day one. I attribute it to slow measured breathing and comfort in the water. Comfort in the water is huge. Swimming laps is good for your heart and good to gain more in water comfort.

It comes with time, so if your SAC Sucks buy/rent a bigger tank! :D
 
First off, the two reasons for breathing are to bring oxygen into the body, and eliminate CO2. It's not very hard to get enough oxygen, especially once you are underwater, and the oxygen in the gas you are breathing is more concentrated than it is on the surface. But CO2 can be hard to get rid of.

To begin with, many new divers pant from anxiety. Panting is rapid, shallow breathing, and it's very poor for gas exchange. The way the respiratory tree is built, the top part of it -- trachea and major bronchi -- is composed of passive conduits, that don't participate in gas exchange. You have to get air all the way down to the small air sacs, or alveoli, in order to deliver oxygen and offload CO2, and if you are panting rapidly, most of the gas you are moving in and out is only ventilating the passive conduits. This is called "dead space", and rapid, shallow breathing basically just exchanges the gas volume in the dead space. If only 10% of what you pull out of the tank is actually participating in gas exchange, you're going to have to breathe a LOT of volume to get rid of your CO2. This is why people commonly describe a scuba breathing pattern that is somewhat deeper and slower than what you use on land, because that minimizes pure dead space ventilation. This deeper and slower idea, though, does not go as far as skip breathing, which is breathing in, holding your breath for a period, and then exhaling. Skip breathing will generally RAISE CO2, and CO2 makes you both stupid and anxious.

It's also true that you have to breathe ENOUGH to get rid of the CO2 you generate, even if your breathing pattern is absolutely efficient. The corollary, therefore, is that anything you can do to reduce your CO2 generation may permit you to pull less air out of your tank in any given period of time. CO2 is generated by muscle activity (and metabolism in general), so the less you move, the less you have to breathe. But to move less, you have to master stability.

One of the common patterns for new divers is to dive out of trim, and usually feet-low. This occurs because many equipment setups put all the weight low on the diver's body, and also because we are upright, terrestrial creatures, who don't find floating in a horizontal posture to be natural at all. But if your feet are below you, and aimed at the bottom, then every kick you make pushes you upward -- and to avoid ascending, you have to stay negative, so there is an equal and opposite force blocking you from rising in the water column. This means that, for every kick, a substantial amount of energy is being expended to go absolutely NOWHERE! If you can orient yourself so that the kicking force goes straight out behind you, you will move only forward, and you will waste less energy.

In addition, a diver who is not relaxed and stable will often use his hands to try to correct his problems. Hands are terrible underwater -- they're very small and give you very little propulsive force for a given amount of effort. (Think about how easy it is to move your hand through the water, compared with the effort it takes to move a fin!) So if you are hand-swimming, you are using a lot of muscle power to do very little -- and all that effort creates CO2 you have to get rid of.

Another way to cope with instability is to play bicycle -- everybody knows a bicycle is MUCH harder to ride slowly than it is to ride fast. Unstable divers swim, and the faster they swim, the more stable they become. But they see less, because they miss all the camouflaged stuff -- and they blow through gas. Slowing down extends your tank, but to slow down, you have to learn to be stable without swimming.

Proper weighting and effective weight distribution, coupled with good body posture, allows diver stability in horizontal trim, which allows the diver to move more slowly and with greater relaxation. Relaxed divers don't pant. The sum is vastly reduced gas consumption.
 
Nicely said, Lynne.

This stable, relaxed, neutral position is the end to keep in mind as you progress.

Excellent post.

~~~~~
Claudette


"If you can't explain it simply, you don't understand it well enough."
--Albert Einstein
 
Well, I go through a tank about 50psi/min at 15-20 feet.

Any advice on how I can work to lower the consumption? How to breath properly.

If I will try to hold the breath a tad longer than it feels natural to breath, will I be building excess of CO2 in my body?


1. cardio

2. dive more

3. be still when hovering

4. be efficient when kicking
 
I want to try this too. Have you figured out yet how to eat doritos with a snorkel?

Like Paladin said crush them into a power; at that time you can make a slurry mix with with salsa and flush it all down with a Corona :drunks:

The chicken wings and pizza is still a work in progress. :facepalm:
 
If I will buy double steel 130's tanks, will I be able to lift them or they will crush me?

PS: Why are tanks called 80, 120, 130, etc? Is it its height in centimeters or some other units?
 
It is how many cubic feet of air they hold at their rated pressure, as you get more dives you will become more comfortable breathing underwater. You should be able to hover motionless in the water, no hand waving or kicking, practice makes perfect.
 
I was convinced, before my first doubles dive, that I was going to stand up with the tanks on and all of my vertebrae were going to crumble until I was about 18 inches tall . . . I still feel that way, sometimes!

If you're a new diver diving with a lot of experienced people, it's not a BAD strategy to buy or rent a bigger tank (it gives you more time underwater, too). And if you are a very BIG person, a bigger tank may be a long-term solution, because bigger people have more body to make CO2, and have to breathe more, no matter how efficient they become, than someone who is smaller. But it's a bad answer to buy a bigger tank because you can't or don't want to fix the problems that are causing the high gas consumption in the first place. Besides, the more you master stability, the more fun diving becomes!
 
I pretty much skipped through so I may have missed this already being posted, but I took 2Kg off my weights (turns out this is actually a better weight for me) which means I need less air to inflate, but then I also started orally inflating too. This helps a lot but only if you blast water out of your reg rather than purging. Don't worry about not having enough air left to blast because you shouldn't be putting large breaths into your bcd anyway. This might help if you're buoyancy isn't brilliant yet and you have to alter it quite often. I also tend to buddy up with less qualified divers so I stay shallower (I don't mind so much - still plenty to see) most of the time and that doesn't improve my SAC in itself but it allows me more time in the water to practice it and also means that I don't have to end the dive and concequently my buddies dive. It's not such a problem normally but if I'm buddied with customers then it's not so good for them to have to end their dive early down to a member of staff's air being low hehe.

Again, it just comes with practice, I can spend twice the time in the water than I could a month and a half ago and that's just after 15 or so dives and I'm sure that's not solely to do with the things I just mentioned.
 
And if you are a very BIG person, a bigger tank may be a long-term solution, because bigger people have more body to make CO2, and have to breathe more, no matter how efficient they become, than someone who is smaller.

So, what are you insinuating here TSandM???? I'm not big, I'm just... well, you see... it happened like this... crap, okay. I'm big. Now hand me that PB&J will ya'? :D


I'm only 235 lbs.. Stark naked. Without the prosthetic on. After fasting for two days, and breathing helium. By the time I get the prosthetic and required liners, sleeves and doohickeys on, tennis shoes, and shorts and a t-shirt, I'm about the 250 mark. Throw a full scuba rig on top of that with an AL80 and lead - let's just say the boat tends to lean toward whichever side I'm sitting on. An AL80 on me looks like an AL63 on my wife - and she STILL manages to stay down longer than me.
 

Back
Top Bottom