That might be true if you buy new from a local shop. I buy most of my gear online, and wait for really good deals or auctions that don't draw lots of bidding, I've hooked up several people with good sets of used dive gear that they can turn around and sell for at least what they paid for it and probably even make money on the resale.
Most everything you get onlineis cheaper. things i reference buying from a LDS is perhaps wet suits or at least trying them on before buying cause sending them back over and over again takes so long.
It's been my experience that a BPW is not for new divers, it's something that divers evolve into over time as they develop skills. It's also my understanding that a BPW is going to cost a heck of a lot more than a basic weight integrated BCD by the time you're done putting it altogether and adding the basics to it.
I cant argue with your understanding, and i agree to a point but by the time you put on 20# and you have to buy another jacket instead of a new 20$ web belt the costs truley show them selves. Other than that the cost for forst time buyers are relativly the same. I dont know what other things oy are refering to adding the basics to it..
My preferred order when hooking up a new diver is Mask/Fins/Snorkel. You can often find them used and cheap on Craiglist or other classified sites, and have the opportunity to try them on for fit. Then a computer if they plan to do dives deeper than say shallow 30 ft reefs, because the rental cost of a computer is typically $10 a day or more, and a good used computer can be found for under $100 and if you own it, you know how it works which can make a big difference in a new sport that can easily become "task overloaded". The dive computer I use is over 10 years old, it's two button and only 2 submenus and is very easy to navigate through. Newer computers are not necessarily better, but they're always more expensive.
Yes i willagree with you the emphasis on simple to use fo me is the important aspect. If you cant find it you dont have it to use.
I assume that anyone thqt has completed OW now has their own basic gear. Is that no longer a requirement prior to starting the class.
Next get yourself some exposure protection based on the sort of diving you plan to be doing, be it a dive skin for the tropics or a 7mm for coldwater diving, or both.
The expusure protection IMO is the first needed to have after basic gear. every thing has to be made to fit and work around it. including BCD weighting systems, fin buoyancy etc.
Finally get yourself a BCD and regulator set to finish off your list, you can buy locally but there are several qualified regulator technicians that sell recently serviced and inspected gear for much less than you'll pay at a brick and mortar shop.