There are two sides to every story:
Cochran's warranty is for two years to the original owner, although we do bend this occasionally for a customer.
The Cochran Gemini in question was originally sold in October 2003 to a "Malcolm" for $675
We have no records on the unit for the next ten years
In November 2013 a "Michael" sends the unit to us for a repair quote
We respond to "Michael" that the unit is not repairable but we will replace it for $595 and replace the worn Wrist strap and scratched lens for free.
We then receive an email from a "Clark" who says he is refunding "Michaels" purchase price.
(We can only assume that at some time "Michael" purchased the unit from "Clark", we don't know when, what condition, or for how much. We also dont know how the unit got from the original purchaser Malcolm to Clark)
We then get another email from "Clark" wanting us to ask "Michael" to pay for the repairs.
We then see a ScubaBoard post by Sparky5149 making numerous, inflammatory, false, and libelous statements.
Based on the evidence, we assume that Sparky5149 is actually Clark and he sold the ten year old unit to Michael.
Also, in his latest email, Clark sent us a link to the Sparky5149 post and said Enjoy the new threads youve started.
While we cannot get involved in the transaction between Clark and Michael, we have made Michael aware that we will work with him.