No, I don't think so, it is more like the third option, a spoiled cry baby. That is indeed you for sure.
I'm not taking the bait . Excellent effort, though.
---------- Post added May 7th, 2015 at 10:28 AM ----------
Do you expect that, when you get the correct shotgun, if the firing pin should break through a manufacturers defect on the 20th box of shells (I easily shot 20-40 boxes of shells every Saturday when I was shooting competitively) that the shop (maybe they are also a smith) will offer to replace the gun, repair the gun, or refund you when you ask to return it?
I think for a firing pin, it would be a repair. I think that would be analagous to a strap breaking. You need it for the item to to work, but it such a failure of the firing pin/spring strap does not ruin the integrity of the entire product. What failed on the fins (the foot pocket) is the equivalent of a barrel failure. If a barrel failed duirng that first 20 boxes of shells (and way beyond), I'd definitely want a replacement and so would you, I'm guessing.