What is unfair and also problematic is limiting the ability of "authorized" dealers to compete with grey market vendors selling the same stuff. It is problematic as it is not fair not to allow it, but if you did, the margin gets very thin for most local dive shops and they bring in even less cash in a market where the profit margin is already razor thin.
As far as I know, and I get this from people in the retail LDS industry, is that the typical LDS has a 100% markup on items such as regulators. In fact, when you buy a Scubapro regulator at the allowed 10% off from an LDS you are paying double what the LDS payed for that reg (100% markup). So if you were to pay full price you payed 110%. I don't know if Aqualung is the same or not.
Many of the other items in an LDS are set at a 100% markup. In virtually every other retail environment 100% markup was gone by the mid 80's. Now other retail businesses have to be happy with 30 to 50% markups.
I used to work in the exercise equipment retail business in the late 70's and early 80's. Stores like Oshman's, Big 5 and other big sports discounters began to come in and carry more and more olympic weights and benches and other stuff like that at discounted prices. There was no way the store I worked for could keep their 100% markup on regular household stuff, so they went more into the high end commercial line. People would rather save money so they'd go to the big discounters, even though the small shop carried better stuff,
people didn't care about the difference between household and commercial quality they just want cheap. This is what ended the small exercise equipment store. The problem I see with dive equipment is it's not a better brand that's more money at the LDS, it's the same stuff over the internet that's way cheaper.
Why would people spend $500 for something locally when you could get the same exact thing for $300 online. When it comes to supporting the LDS it's hard for people to justify dropping hundreds more just to support a business that can't compete. It's kind of like a welfare or mercy, but at some point people can't do it anymore.
What's razor thin isn't the profit margin in an LDS, it's the amount of sales and the fact that there aren't that many divers coming in buying stuff. Retail space is astronomical and wages keep going up.This is what's thinning out profits. I see the future of a local LDS merging in with larger sports retailers and having a corner in the store. Sport Chalet did this, and even though Sport Chalet isn't doing well overall, their dive section is still covered by the rest of the store. They are able to discount their stuff 10 to 15% overall in the dive section which gives them a local advantage. This is where a lot of people get their air too.
I think this is what it's coming to as far as the LDS.