Divingblueberry
Contributor
I've not yet read through the remaining responses but wanted to echo Christie's advice. I can speak from personal experience.
Our second dive trip after being certified was to Cozumel. We selected a dive op on the recommendation of our LDS (local dive shop). It was a small operation and was perfect. As new divers, I didn't realize how helpful it would be to have the personal attention and advice from the DM. He could only provide that because it was a small group. I learned so much more on that trip than on our first trip which was on a cattle boat in St Lucia.
I also experienced some unexpected anxiety. I had never been in the kinds of current that are common on Cozumel. Our DM spent quite a bit of time with me and helped me to gain the confidence I needed. Since we had communicated with him via email prior to our trip he knew that we were brand new divers. Consequently he selected sites that were appropriate to our experience. 6 years on we still dive with him when we are in Coz. We don't need as much of his attention these days but I still appreciate the smaller groups.
Whatever you decide, have a great time. Cozumel is really special.
I really appreciate your comment. It confirms what I was thinking about having the chance to start on the right foot and go for dives that are appropriate for my skills and experience.
Thanks !