@Wibble, I have to agree with @The Chairman. This is how open water students should look. It isn't hard if the instructor focuses on establishing comfort in the water with a solid foundation.
6 Tips to improve Buoyancy & Trim
- Thread starter Macan
- Start date
Please register or login
Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.
Benefits of registering include
- Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
- A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
- You can make this box go away
Great tips. New divers may wonder "why bother?". The answer is that good buoyancy and trim will reduce gas consumption. Many people, myself included also find it a more comfortable way to dive. This is somewhat subjective and someone will say that they are completely comfortable in the demented seahorse position. Each to their own.
Absolutely.
However, with good trim and buoyancy comes
the requirement to fin properly. That’s uncommon in the recreational world.
After the PADI Advanced there’s the Peak Performance Buoyancy. That won’t be teaching frog kick and helicopter turns.
There’s also the attitude of some recreational divers who aren’t interested in flat trim.
Recreational kit doesn’t help flat trim — the picture/video shows a wing and harness, not a jacket BCD. Also the lack of danglies indicates a long hose and necklaced backup, not an octopus with a loose primary hose, the SPG isn’t dangling, etc.
Whilst a few instructors may teach these techniques am happy to wager that most AOW students — and instructors for that matter — won’t be exposed to fundies/technical style diving.
Finally, my personal experience with developing the skills shown in that clip (it doesn’t show the associated finning techniques) was it took a long time to be that stable. My recreational friends/buddies at that time showed no interest in developing those “technical” techniques.
Don't be fooled by the maketing material. Most people that have at least average talent for learing physical activity will fall into proper trim when given the right amount of weight. The gear, dangling stuff and hand position have no bearing on trim and bouyancy.
The reason why you find good material from (only) gue is that they are the only onee who produce good marketing material and have understood that you have to push the product online with tons of footage that looks cool to new divers. Unfortunately, virtually all other agencies are run pretty amateur hour-ish. An agencies like RAID can't even figure out that you need a instructor search function on the website but it doesn't mean that the instructors don't know entry level stuff.
That's utter nonsense. The type bcd or fins or whatever else gear you use has no bearing on trim or bouyancy.
jadairiii
Contributor
- Messages
- 1,146
- Reaction score
- 1,670
That was how my daughter looked after one day in the pool during her Rec 1.
Here we were 2 weeks ago, mild current on the wreck. It is not hard to teach this to new students, its hard to teach it to "old" students, who refuse to take the cotton out of their ears and put it in their mouth.....
Attachments
That's something I keep hearing but is not true in my experience. I dove with a couple of people from another club a while back and I took 5 or 6 kg kg from one guy after the first dive and he trimmed out way better the dive after, without any further training or advice. I've seen that over and over again.
It's super easy to trim out as long as you're not carrying too much weight. Not need to make it seem like it's difficult... well, unless you're trying to sell a classes.
I have not been in the Cave Adventurers shop in Florida for a few years, but the last time I was there, they had a sign with the silhouette of a diver exhibiting perfect buoyancy and trim during a dive. That logo was made from a photo of an actual diver showing that "advanced" technique. The subject of the photo was a student in an OW class.
Any instructor in any agency who focuses on buoyancy and trim from the start will produce divers who look like that.
Any instructor in any agency who focuses on buoyancy and trim from the start will produce divers who look like that.
I was gonna say.....I show OW students from minute one in the pool that they need to maintain a "diver position". I know many of you do as well. They catch on quickly if you set a standard. They don't all "get it" and it takes more work after training is done to get good, but most look pretty decent by the time they head to OW. I think sometimes students struggle because we sell them short on ability instead of challenging them.
The Chairman
Chairman of the Board
They don't teach them.
They don't set the example.
Monkey see, monkey do.
Students want to dive JUST like their instructors. If you don't kneel: they won't. If you don't lie on the bottom: they won't either. If you show them how to be neutral and use only your fins: they will emulate.
Similar threads
