GrumpyOldGuy
Contributor
Well, *I'm* not staying away from it because I think it's dangerous. I'm not buying one because I have no need of one.
And if you want to claim an argument is illogical, (good grief!) to claim the product is "dangerous" because it's emergency equipment and not enough people have adopted it and so the lack of any documented problems doesn't disprove the hypothesis that it's dangerous... and so it must be, actually, dangerous... because you say so...
now that, my dear sir, is illogical!
E
Actually, I only pointed out we cannot make any conclusions based on accident reports (or lack of) as you claimed.
My concern is simple it is very different and has no real benefit. Being different is fine for lots of stuff, but for an alternate air supply to be used in an emergency and possibly by an inexperienced diver / buddy it is not such a good idea. In this case, a certain amount of uniformity is good, boring but good.