Blue Magic is our pick for Cozumel

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

I'm not a first-time poster (although d_aviddiver looks pretty close to being one) and have posted numerous comments, both positive and negative, about dive ops over a number of years. I won't re-post any of my previously-posted comments about Blue Magic here as there's no particular utility in doing so.

Many previous posts address all the questions raised by d_aviddiver, and a quick search will find that information with little difficulty. To summarize based on multiple trips since shortly after Blue Magic opened:

bottom times - depends on your SAC rate and nitrogen loading. These are not predetermined by BMS.

sites dived - wherever the divers want, within the confines of practicality and safety (especially weather). We tend to like Maracaibo and the Punta Sur sites, but Joyce has been encouraging us to head for Barracuda when we're there in February. I haven't heard that they go to any of the more exotic sites (e.g., on the eastern side).

depth allowed - we usually decide this based on our dive plan to balance bottom time vs. seeing what's there. We had a diver on one trip who wanted to test out his homemade light at 160 feet. He did, but the rest of us stayed at 120.

docks used - pretty much the same as most other ops, as far as I can tell. We actually like going to the caleta, so get on the boat there. We've picked up other divers at most of the southern docks. I don't know about northern ones.

services provided
gear cleaning and storage - yes, if you want and are diving with them for a few days.
water - of course, and plenty of it. No other beverages provided.
snacks - fruit, usually a variety including melon, banana, papaya, maybe mango.

Some questions not asked above include:

boats - as far as I can tell, these are the former Scuba Staff's four 6-packs, all hauled and refurbished within the last year. They have new, large engines, full canopies, and foam deck matting.

equipment - all the boats we've been on carry oxygen, first aid, and radios. Every time there's been nitrox on-board, there's been an analyzer.

towels - dry, fluffy.

rental gear - at least when my nephew rented gear from them, it was fairly new and well-maintained.

arrangements - things have been very organized and on-time.

handling of emergencies - haven't seen one, so can't say.​

For those familiar with Sandro's and Gabriel's last place of employment, BMS seems more organized and tightly-run. Sandro is the general manager.

To be extra-clear: nobody at Blue Magic Scuba has ever asked me to post a review, let alone a positive one. This includes Sando and Gabriel, whom we've considered friends for years before they joined BMS, and the owners Joyce and Mark. We happily do favors for them, such as bringing athletic shoes or nutritional supplements, but wouldn't do reviews as favors.

I think the reason that there are multiple positive reviews of this dive operator is that they are warranted.
 
Well put, BaileyM and kwest! Actually, kind of nice to see differing opinions and points of view without it disolving into a pissin' match. That is how it should be on this board. I remember when I started wanting to dive warm waters, and coming to this board for input. Now, years later, I still come to this board for input. Lets make sure the board is receptive to both the new posters and the seasoned posters.
 
Good post mstevens. It contains information that makes it helpful to a diver trying to decide between dive shops.

You're right, I'm not a frequent poster here. I check the Cozumel board here from time to time because I have a condo at El Cantil and many ties to the island.

I am active on the Diver to Diver message board.

At no time did I intend to criticize new posters (I am one and am not in the habit of shooting myself in the foot), but I was pointing out a "trend" of two posts (later I was informed by PM that is was three) in one week all putting out a glowing report of an op without any information. It was the lack of information that was my issue. Without facts or information the posts are just an opinion and, IMHO, not helpful.

Edited to say: Good grief, man, if your op wants to take you to Barracuda..GO! One of my favorites due to: quality and quantity of the marine life (things grow bigger up there, or so it seems), the beautiful reef & wall (and it's pristine condition) & the excitement - you just never know what to expect, eg wild currents and lots of life or mild currents and great vis. Just trying to give you some "facts" to go with the opinion ;-)

FWIW, a few years ago on the D2D board there were almost daily posts praising another Coz dive op. They were practically word for word and that practice created some bad will towards the operator.
 
Great points of view from all. It's nice to see this thread not resort to a pissing match. We all have our favorite ops for one reason or another. :)
 
I have a condo at El Cantil

Right. Now I have seething jealousy to contend with. Thanks for that. At least tell me the seagulls crap up your windows and make the place a living hell, or all the supermodels' blatant disregard for basic modesty has become tiresome, or something.

Good grief, man, if your op wants to take you to Barracuda..GO!

We're going, we're going!

There's been a conspiracy to keep us away from Barracuda. Some trips it's been the mix of divers (such as when we were diving with a nephew who was doing his OW referral) or the fact that our kid is just recently big enough for me not to worry about him in significant currents. Sometimes it's been weather (we're apparently both Norte-magnets and hurricane attractants). Often it's just that the list of sites we want to visit is longer than the number of dives we can fit in.
 
Right. Now I have seething jealousy to contend with. Thanks for that. At least tell me the seagulls crap up your windows and make the place a living hell, or all the supermodels' blatant disregard for basic modesty has become tiresome, or something.

On our last trip there were a couple of very lovely 20ish females that loved to "pose" in their bikinis on the ocean side wall of the infinity pool (it's several feet wide).

The Naval station is only a couple hundred yards from El Cantil and we were very well "protected" that week by the very close, slow, drive-bys from the gun boats - all hands on deck!
 
Dear d_aviddiver,
I posted the "happy post" for Blue Magic. Yes it was my first post. I've been a member of Scubaboard for a year but never had much to say. My apologies about not giving out my dive locations, depths and the specific food provided on the boat. Unfortunately, I'm back working at my business and didn't really throw my all into my post like you did. All I can say is that with 40 meager dives under my belt, I found Blue Magic to be very enjoyable to dive with.

Say, when you're diving, do you take the chip on your shoulder into account for weight?
 
mrhappydiver try to understand that first time poster spam is a reality and you may see where these folks are coming from. Don't take what's been said here as a personal attack - you're just a string of letters in a name on this here internet board until you've posted a few times and people get to know you, so there's nothing personal about it. Instead, take it as an opportunity to expound on the topic you've started and let people get to know you.
 

Back
Top Bottom