My dive buddies and i have just returned from a relaxing dive trip without incident. We planned our dive and dove our plan. After hundreds of dives together and instructor certifications we still periodically asked if the others were ok and how much air we had. We agree that diving as a task is not difficult. We also agree we had excellent instruction from instructors who answered to an agency with rigorous standards. So when divers on our boat under direct instruction came up bent. The question arose who is to blame? When Gilboa quarry has not changed its profile but incidents and accidents are at all time high, who is to blame. The divers, instructors and agencies all have a stake in each sucessful dive, but when something goes wrong does the blame go up the chain? We have argued alot about this what do you think?