Too many places for air to get trapped, especially if the wing wraps around the tank.
Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.
Benefits of registering include
When the bladder is too big it tends to "taco" the tank. That can lead to air being trapped on one side of the tank and not fully deflating when you want it to. A more compact wing, 28-32lbs of lift, is in the ideal range for lift for single tank diving. Even in cold water with a pony and 30lbs of lead on me (belt and BP/W waist pockets) I'm still using a 32lb wing. I'm looking to get a 40+lb wing for when I move to doubles.What is the concern with too big of a bladder? Serious question as I dont know.
I think you're making the right call. The first BC I bought for myself was the Dimension with the I3 inflator. Sold it after about 30 dives. Taco city.Ok so it sounds like that BCD is out of the equation. Too bad. It feels very nice. I will keep trying stuff on at my other LDS’s and see what else feels good.
I wonder why they put such a large bladder on it? Wonder if its a safety thing to allow for a lot of lift if someone is overweighted?I think you're making the right call. The first BC I bought for myself was the Dimension with the I3 inflator. Sold it after about 30 dives. Taco city.
When the bladder is too big it tends to "taco" the tank. That can lead to air being trapped on one side of the tank and not fully deflating when you want it to. A more compact wing, 28-32lbs of lift, is in the ideal range for lift for single tank diving. Even in cold water with a pony and 30lbs of lead on me (belt and BP/W waist pockets) I'm still using a 32lb wing. I'm looking to get a 40+lb wing for when I move to doubles.
For tropic diving, an 18-20lb wing would be sufficient with AL 80s. For a good all around single tank wing stick to the 30-32lb range. They hug the tank and generally avoid trapping air. The other thing to consider is bladder shape. For a back inflate or BP/W a donut is best imo. Horseshoe style where the bladder is not connected at the bottom "can" be a bit more finicky in dumping air.What is the best way to determine how large of a wing you need? Also how are most people figuring out the amount of weights you need? I rent my BCDs and I ask them their opinion on weights. They have been pretty spot on and I have documented my weights in my log.
Hi,I have over 200 dives on my Dimension and I love it. The bladder is big but it is never close to full on the surface while getting on the boat or doing a swim out shore diving. I never felt while in close quarters that anything was going to snag. It has 2 roll up storage pockets and for the most part I like the weight set up.I use the octo holder and route my gauges under the velcro hold downs. . pretty streamlined Very comfortable
I have over 200 dives on my Dimension and I love it. The bladder is big but it is never close to full on the surface while getting on the boat or doing a swim out shore diving. I never felt while in close quarters that anything was going to snag. It has 2 roll up storage pockets and for the most part I like the weight set up.I use the octo holder and route my gauges under the velcro hold downs. . pretty streamlined Very comfortable