Tyler. Henry
Registered
Do either of these have a distinct advantage - except for the comfort swivel?
LDS services both. Thanks for the help.
LDS services both. Thanks for the help.
Atomic Z2 vs Zeagle F8
- Thread starter Tyler. Henry
- Start date
Please register or login
Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.
Benefits of registering include
- Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
- A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
- You can make this box go away
The atomic is a piston, if you want it sealed it uses grease which adds to the cost when serviced, the F8 is diaphragm and sealed, service is simpler and should be cheaper.
second stages both have the same seat saver, atomic has an automatic (AFC) predive /dive system and the Zeagle uses the common rotating dive/predive (I prefer the Zeagle) both are very high performance. The Z2 doesn’t have the comfort swivel on the second stage, that’s the Z3 but I haven’t looked at them lately so it may be on the Z2 now, really don’t know but I am also not a fan of the comfort swivel, I use an Omni and a long hose.
The Z2 does not have a swivel. That is one of the reasons I choose it over the Z3.
The Z2 has a bottom LP port. The F8 does not (as far as I can tell). That by itself would be reason enough for me to pick the Z2 over the F8.
I like to use the bottom port on a single tank reg set for the longer hose 2nd stage, so it runs straight down from the 1st stage and loops under my right arm - instead of starting by running out to the side, then bending down to go under my arm.
The Z2 has a bottom LP port. The F8 does not (as far as I can tell). That by itself would be reason enough for me to pick the Z2 over the F8.
I like to use the bottom port on a single tank reg set for the longer hose 2nd stage, so it runs straight down from the 1st stage and loops under my right arm - instead of starting by running out to the side, then bending down to go under my arm.
Ha ha! Thank you, but I don't think that is necessary.I think you can handle an F8shall I send you one to try out?
It's not about what will work. They would both work. It's about what I PREFER. And I PREFER the hose routing from using a bottom LP port.Besides, I have enough of your stuff on loan...
Scuba-guy
Contributor
I own 2 zeagle F8, its their top of the line. I like it.
Zeagle F8 = $650
Atomic Z2 = $570
And, straight from Zeagle's page: "To create this regulator, Zeagle collaborated with Atomic Aquatics..."
Notice that Atomic doesn't offer a regulator that they collaborated with anyone else on...
I have no doubt that the F8 is a very fine regulator. Don't take this as knocking it in any way.
But, $80 less and the Z2 gives you a bottom port (which you certainly do not have to use if you don't want to)....
Atomic Z2 = $570
And, straight from Zeagle's page: "To create this regulator, Zeagle collaborated with Atomic Aquatics..."
Notice that Atomic doesn't offer a regulator that they collaborated with anyone else on...
I have no doubt that the F8 is a very fine regulator. Don't take this as knocking it in any way.
But, $80 less and the Z2 gives you a bottom port (which you certainly do not have to use if you don't want to)....
Owned by the same company, the best thing is I found a new F8 for a touch over $500and bought a used one for just over 300. I like the sealed first stage better and it’s part of the deal on the Zeagle, just easier since I do my own service but the Z is an amazingly good regulator and it doesn’t put you behind anyone performance wise.
Similar threads
