Yet another thread about Wing Size, sorry.

[jonnythan]

In this situation it's not that your wing isn't big enough, it's that you're not properly weighted.

As for Fishy, from full to empty your largest tank (120) will have a 9 lb. swing, which you'll need to compensate with weight, so at the beginning of a dive you'll be somewhere in the neighborhood of 20 lbs. negative, any of the wings you posted will work, I personally love my DR Venture.

Ben

I love the advertising for the Venture wing:

Dive Rite Venture Wings are the most compact air cell designed specifically for applications combining single cylinders, of up to 95 cubic feet/15 litres, with a rigid back plate/harness configuration or the Dive Rite TransPac harness. This wing will work with the largest of single tanks and is constructed of heavy-duty ballistic nylon

95 cf is "the largest of single tanks"?

 

[jonnythan]

ABQ, let me assure you that Lake Huron is not temperate water.

 

[OneBrightGator]

I love the advertising for the Venture wing:
95 cf is "the largest of single tanks"?

Very nice Jon, I dunno who's doing the testing at Dive Rite, but I recently had my Venture down to 100 feet with a single 104, SS plate and cannister light.

Ben

 

[ABQdiver]

ABQ, let me assure you that Lake Huron is not temperate water.

No, in fact its anything but. However, many people do travel for diving excursions that are to tropical locations and a smaller wing would fill the ticket if that was the case.