What a DISMAL article... Should have been entitled "A novice diver's guide to the only 10 wrecks I've ever seen". I'm guessing the author; (1) is an American and (2) took short vacations in Malta and the Red Sea whilst still holding only an OW card...
I agree that the article, particularly in the context of the title ('most incredible') is quite poor. I actually do not think the author was American - probably Asian, based on the grammar and syntax, either writing in English or submitting to the vagaries of translation. But, the article and some of the response comments do raise some interesting questions.
What constitutes an appealing wreck to dive? I think the answer varies according to an individual's personal interest. Andy's comment - that his bucket list would include only wrecks that have not been visited by divers before - is one perspective. I can easily see that.
Personally, I have interest in wrecks that have historical meaning - we have a lot of wrecks of the NC coast that were sunk during WWII. I am fascinated to dive them, and I feel like I am touching history when I do - human beings engaged in mortal combat on these vessels, and some / many died while doing so. I cannot help but be moved by that concept. (I am also fascinated and moved by hiking trails where other human beings walked thousands of years before - I feel I am somehow 'touching' those humans by putting my feet on the same trail that they walked.)
But, I am also fascinated to dive wrecks that attract a lot of marine life. The wreck is somewhat trivial in those cases - it is merely a magnet for marine life. There are some NC wrecks that have history, but I often neglect that history because of what I see on them (rays, sharks, etc)
Personally, I have been on the Spiegel Grove many times, and I find it to be a bit of a sterile wreck. What has been appealing to me is diving it before and after it was turned upright by storm action. I like diving the 'O' because the size of the screws is truly impressive. It is probably as close as I will ever get to that part of an aircraft carrier. Frankly, I find the Prince Albert to be boring. Even the Hilma Hooker offers more appeal, if only because of some of the rumor and story-telling that goes on about it.
There are plenty of incredible shipwrecks that I can never dive. The Titanic was mentioned, and I consider that to be near / at the top of the list of 'incredible'. The Arizona is on that list as well, because of the significance of the events that led to its sinking. The Edmund Fitzgerald is on that list.
My
diving 'bucket list'? I have to include the Doria, irrespective of the current state of deterioration. It is an icon. (Actually, I would like to dive the Empress of Ireland even more.) I would add the wrecks in Truk / Chuuk. I would also add the Saratoga, simply because of the history. There are some interesting, and somewhat deeper wrecks in the water off the VA / NC coast that are grouped together as the 'Billy Mitchell fleet'. I would like to touch those.
But those are my preferences. To each his / her own. Diving a wreck can be meaningful for personal reasons, whether it is an artificial reef, a warship sunk in hostile action, or a non-military vessel that came to grief because of weather, incompetence, or bad luck.