Will new resort threaten Sipadan?

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

vladimir

The Voice of Reason
Messages
44,661
Reaction score
65,263
# of dives
I just don't log dives
My guess? Yes. Here's the article from AsiaOneNews:

Will new resort threaten Malaysia's top dive spot?

An oceanarium resort planned near the world-famous Sipadan diving spot off Malaysian Borneo could spell disaster for the region's delicate coral reefs, say environmentalists. -AFP

Tue, Nov 18, 2008
AFP

KUALA LUMPUR - AN OCEANARIUM resort planned near the world-famous Sipadan diving spot off Malaysian Borneo could spell disaster for the region's delicate coral reefs, environmentalists said on Tuesday.

The plan for the huge resort, complete with an artificial reef and research facilities, has also come under attack from indigenous Bajau or 'sea gypsies' who say it infringes on their native rights.

The oceanarium resort is slated to be built on a 33-hectare site on Mabul island, located just next to Sipadan, which is famous for its coral reefs, teeming sea life and crystal clear waters.

Reports said plans for the resort, touted as 'a marine habitat wonder', include fake sea grass and other devices to attract fish, as well as the construction of swimming pools and more than 200 bungalows and villas.

Environmentalists have criticised the plan, which will require tonnes of construction materials to be brought in by barges, saying it could destroy the island's marine life and degrade the corals off nearby Sipadan.

Sabah Environmental Protection Association president Wong Teck said there were fears of a repeat of a 2006 accident on Sipadan when a construction barge ran aground, destroying a coral reef patch the size of three tennis courts.

'Mabul has an extremely sensitive marine ecology and the plan for a new oceanarium is certain to affect the environment there badly,' he said.

'An increase in the number of people staying on the island as a result of the resort and the amount of waste created, in addition to the construction work right on the coral and shallows, are almost certain to destroy much of it.'

'It is definitely not environmentally sustainable and the whole idea of an oceanarium seems quite strange given that people can already see all the fish and sealife in the pristine clear waters without the need for such a facility.'

Bajau villager Fung Haji Sappari also opposed the project, telling the Star newspaper that his people have had customary rights over the land as they have been using the area for fishing, transport and passage for hundreds of years.

'How can they do it? Several years ago I also applied for 15 acres around the same spot. It was not approved,' he told the daily.

Fung said more than 2,000 villagers on the island feared being moved out once the project was complete as the local land office considered them to be squatters.

The Star quoted officials as saying the state cabinet had approved the resort on condition that the project managers would conserve and repair the coral reefs.

However, it said the developers would have to get approval for the project's environmental impact assessment before they can begin work.

Concerns over environmental damage on Sipadan prompted the closure of five dive resorts on the island in 2005, and most visitors now stay on Mabul and travel to the Sipadan reefs by boat. -- AFP
 
That would be a disaster.... at the current limit of divers per day on Sipadan (which I believe is a good thing), you simply cannot have another resort....in fact, they should have less!

If its going to be Kapalai and Mabul muck diving on offer, I would go to Lembeh instead....
 
This is just GREAT! More competition for those dang dive permits to Sipidan. Soon it will be not who ya know but who you ....!!!!
Crazy!
 
I can't see how such a monstrous development wouldn't impact the area negatively. It's so frustrating how Malaysia continues to be so short-sighted with treasures in its possession. Classic case of the goose that laid the golden eggs. But I'm guess the greedy crooks behind this venture have never read cautionary fables.
 
https://www.shearwater.com/products/perdix-ai/

Back
Top Bottom