Bottom line is that there aren't many "bad" choices on Bonaire. It's a matter of finding what best matches your desires and going for it.
This has been our experience too, and the primary reason we've had a lot of fun over the years looking for new places to stay.
Only a few made our short list for repeat visits:
- Buddy Dive (back in the late 90's, before Bart left to start Wannadive, and before BD took over the Lion's Dive property.) We still stop by to visit with Murph at happy hour.
- Yachtclub Apartments (before the change in ownership and addition of the restaurant) was a great value and offered a shared outdoor BBQ/eating area.
- Beachcomber Villas, for the reasons mentioned in my post above.
I'd still recommend all of the other places we've stayed, like Belmar Oceanfront Apartments and Happy Holiday Homes etc. But with so many other quality options we didn't feel that they warranted repeat stays. We feel that Beachcomber Villas is something special. The reviews on their VRBO site echo our experience and enthusiasm.
Occasionally I read posts that say something like "XYZ Resort is absolutely the best place to stay, and we wouldn't ever consider staying anywhere else. We've stayed there all 99 times we've been to Bonaire." How do these people know their choice is unarguably the best if they've never stayed elsewhere???
The above reviews are all great!