I've learned the key with AA miles the past few years (and this year) is to BOOK FAR IN ADVANCE. We booked our December 2019 trip RT ORF (Norfolk, VA) to CZM in early April 2019 when MILESAAVERS were still available and it was 12,500 miles each way (25K RT) without overnight layovers anywhere. Now we play the wait and see game and see how the flights may change.
Looking today... MILESAAVER's for all of December for our trip are gone and it's now 27,500 miles each way for AAnytime (55K RT). I'd say If you have miles racked up and missed an early window to book, maybe think about paying cash this time around and use the miles on a future trip when you may have the ability to plan and book FAR in advance instead of burning enough miles for 2 future trips on 1 trip now?
I do need to thank the OP for reminding me it was time to dump my wife's card and grab another. My wife and I each grabbed 60,000 mile Barclay's cards in Dec 2017 that I posted about here...
OK... American Airlines / Barclay Bank sold me on this airmiles card.
It is time to ditch my wife's Barclay's AA card and I just grabbed her a new Citi AA card tonight with another 60,000 bonus sign-up miles. The annual fee is waived the first year and we just have to run $3,000 total through it in the first 3 months to grab the 60,000 miles which is no big deal as we run EVERYTHING through our miles cards. Another 60,000 miles to burn and more free trips on miles.
Oh, for those who believe playing the air miles credit card game and swapping from one bank's card to the next to the next is somehow going to impact your credit score... Both my wife and I have 850 credit scores. Swapping from one bank's card to another after you've burned through the miles has ABSOLUTELY NO IMPACT ON YOUR CREDIT SCORE. Out with the old burned up air miles card (as soon as all miles are recorded at AA we'll close that account) and in with the new card and new bonus miles that will hit her AA miles account 4 months from now .
Here is a link to the Citi card I just grabbed her that replaces her Barclay's card from AA's website...
Citi® / AAdvantage® Platinum Select® World Elite™ Mastercard® | AA.com