What BC to use?

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

Thank you for your suggestion. Like I said I am very new to the game and I do appreciate all suggestions. With the back plate, can it be adapted to hold two tanks?
 
I can install doubles on my ScubaPro Classic, however, I don't know how stable it would be.

If you plan to do a lot of diving with doubles, than a BP and wings may be the best way to go.

Let us know what you decide.

The ScubaRedneck

:scuba:
 
Absolutely!! The backplate can do single or double tanks. IMO the backplate can hold doubles far more solidly than any conventional bcd on the market. Also it is more low profile to reduce drag. Not to mention less expensive than modifying a conventional bcd. Oh then there is the ease of changing between tanks, be it singles or doubles. So many positives for a bp/wings setup I don't see why everyone has them.
 
Thanks folks. My DP is watching what you are all saying as well and we are discussing what would be best for me in regards to the kind of diving we will be doing. Like I said I am very new and all opinions are greatly appreciated. :D
 
I never thought about recommending a backplate style rig to a new diver. I can see some advantages. Some disadvantages. I guess a lot depends on individual skill and the skills and confidence of your buddies. I actually have both a jacket style BC and an OMS kit w/backplate, you know, one can never have enough stuff. However they are different, and I like them both.

I am curious to know what ends up in the ol' shopping bag in the end. I hope we find out.........
 
Try a Halcyon Backplate and Pioneer Wing setup.
 
I know they can be used with a single tank, but with singles life is easier with a Transpac or conventional BC. BP problem areas are comfort, crotch strap required, difficulty with adjustment and the single tank is 2" away from the diver's back (1.5" with pioneer built in STA).
 
I will most definitely let you all know what I end up with. I have been told by my DP that I have really strong diving skills already, I don't know to be honest. I know I love the sport and can't wait to start. I do see the advantages to a back plate. I was told that when inflated you go straight up but not sure with the diving situations I am going to be in if I will truly need two tanks (would like them but was TOLD I may not need them) Also being a woman I don't like having the boobs squished (sorry boys). With a full BC you get that, but I will put up with it if I have to, not a biggie. I will keep you all informed as to what I get.
 
well, with a proper woman's BC, that's not an issue.
(so far she has only tried my BC, an aqualung sonic2)
I'm using a backplate and wing, one of gary's, and as soon as we get out, will be letting her try that to see what she thinks.

My personal feeling is that for using singles, the jacket is the EASIEST way to do it (but mabey not the best way)
but I would also like to see her try both ways out to see what she is most comfortable with, so she dosen't waste a pile of money on something she isn't going to use. I have my own opinion on what is the best setup, but acting as a mentor, I want to simply supply the best info I can, and let her come to her own conclusions ;)
The LDS that she is taking her open water with is strictly a recreational facility, and as such does not sell BP/wing setups, or suggest doubles in any way. At this point, I think the way to go would be to run with rental gear until she gets a clear feel for what works well for her.

;)
 

Back
Top Bottom