Herman,
I have two tilt valve regulators, a Healthways Scuba Star and a Sportsways Sport Diver. The Sportsways is exhibiting all the characteristics you described, except it is with the overpressure relief valve. The regulator does not leak, but breaths awfully hard. The Healthways Scuba Star, by contrast, is actually a fairly nice breathing regulator (for the times). It never did leak, and is a simple, dependable regulator (5 moving parts). I got the Scuba Star because that was my second regulator as a kid. I progressed from the Healthways SCUBA to the Scuba Star (double hose to single hose). It breathed better than the Healthways SCUBA, but some of that was simply demand valve positioning. So I haven't had that much problem with tilt valves, even today.
I have had problems with some downstream valves--the Dacor Dart. I finally, in frustration, cut the hose (it takes some doing) about 15 years ago so I would not use it or work on it. It had a really funny action with the demand levers in the second stage, and gave air is two phases (initial and then more air).
SB, I didn't realize that there was a contest going on here. Some of this info we think is self-evident I don't think is being taught or written about anymore. So unless someone has picked up Fred Roberts's Basic Scuba, they may be SOL (an older term, but to some still has some meaning).
SeaRat