Thanks guys. I ended up eating at Marker 4 right by the dive shop one night. Drinks were good, food was not. Not a fish on the menue was local and all crab dishes, including crab cakes were made with imitation crab meat. Overpriced, but that's expected at a place on the water. To top it all off I got sick.
We also ate at a little breakfast place that was pretty good. I forget the name but it had a 57 chevy on the wall inside and lots of Americana. I think it may have been Anitas.
We also ate at another seafood place on 41, good atmosphere, live music, decent food. I forget the name, but I remember a statue of a pig in snorkle gear out front.
We hit Captain Eddies last time and liked it a whole lot more than either of the seafood places above.
Thanks for the input I'll have to check out some of the frosty mug, and Pops next time.