azscubadude
Contributor
Those are different flights, too. The first one involves overnight travel to get to Cozumel, while the less-expensive second one does not.
The whole process is nuts.
The reason the first flight is afternoon and not the early morning Red Eye was because the early morning wouldn't come up in the search. Sometimes Continental shows a 4:45 am flight, sometimes it's 5:00 am and sometimes it's 6:15 am. None of those came up the first search for that day.