justinthedeeps
Contributor
Melbs vis beats Sydney any time, right?
Trip Report Sydney, Australia-April 2024
- Thread starter living4experiences
- Start date
Please register or login
Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.
Benefits of registering include
- Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
- A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
- You can make this box go away
- Messages
- 7,189
- Reaction score
- 6,231
- # of dives
- 2500 - 4999
It's about getoutability
So I am next to my ute fully geared a magnificent day in a puddle of water at Koonya dead calm
and the dude comes up and asks me if I've been in or going in and comes out with how's the vis
Well it is after all our secret divers greeting used by divers non divers and general diver groupies
so I tell him "Who cares about the vis, look at the Ocean!"
and when the weather is still magnificent, in that micro climate that is the Mornington Peninsula
but generally rough in the water you've got Flinders, east side of Cape Schanck and any number
of piers, junk and bottle collecting at Sorrento, if you like current the best scallops you have ever
tasted off the shore in the Sorrento channel and if you like current go flying diving and the most
prolific sponge life and tool collecting, at the Blairgowrie breakwater, or grab a boat and explore
I'm exhausted
All in some of the cleanest pristine most magnificent water you will find
and if it's a bit rough or not there, that boat can take you just around the corner to do incredible
10-20-30-40-50-60-70-80-90-100 metre dives
to rub yourself on rusting steel
So I am next to my ute fully geared a magnificent day in a puddle of water at Koonya dead calm
and the dude comes up and asks me if I've been in or going in and comes out with how's the vis
Well it is after all our secret divers greeting used by divers non divers and general diver groupies
so I tell him "Who cares about the vis, look at the Ocean!"
and when the weather is still magnificent, in that micro climate that is the Mornington Peninsula
but generally rough in the water you've got Flinders, east side of Cape Schanck and any number
of piers, junk and bottle collecting at Sorrento, if you like current the best scallops you have ever
tasted off the shore in the Sorrento channel and if you like current go flying diving and the most
prolific sponge life and tool collecting, at the Blairgowrie breakwater, or grab a boat and explore
I'm exhausted
All in some of the cleanest pristine most magnificent water you will find
and if it's a bit rough or not there, that boat can take you just around the corner to do incredible
10-20-30-40-50-60-70-80-90-100 metre dives
to rub yourself on rusting steel
clownfishsydney
Contributor
When in April did you dive? As pointed out earlier, the weather has been atrocious here for the past 8 weeks or so, with almost record rainfall and huge seas. I have only done 3 dives in the past month since returning from a dive trip to Bali. Normally I would do 10 to 12 at a minimum.
As to the operator, I know that he goes out in conditions that I have cancelled dives on my own (private) boat.
The diving in Sydney is world class and with so much variety. However, you need to know where to go, especially considering the forecast weather conditions. What can be good at one site can be rubbish at another. Anyway, for others thinking of visiting Sydney and diving, don't judge it by the OP's experience.
As to the operator, I know that he goes out in conditions that I have cancelled dives on my own (private) boat.
The diving in Sydney is world class and with so much variety. However, you need to know where to go, especially considering the forecast weather conditions. What can be good at one site can be rubbish at another. Anyway, for others thinking of visiting Sydney and diving, don't judge it by the OP's experience.
Tassi Devil Diver
Contributor
And Hobart beats both of them
DiveDiversions
Registered
Would agree with this, Eagle Hawks nest is spectacular divingAnd Hobart beats both of them
Melbs vs Syd, this I wouldn't agree with.
Have spent 12 months living and diving in Melbourne pre Covid lockdown, when Melbourne is good it it good, when it's bad it utter rubbish!
It's considerable colder above and below the water then Sydney, and this is why they get the better vis at times, but they also go through worse weather spells then Sydney (although of late I think both are on par)
And Melbourne's shore diving is basically shallow piers, of which only a couple are decent (Flinders, Rye and Portsea)
Whereas Sydney's shore diving has various topographies of beaches, bays and the harbour that provides a lot a variations to your diving.
Melbourne also has crabs (and they lock down the slightest hint of a virus
)Melbourne does have more wrecks then Sydney does (ex HMAS Canberra is an awesome wreck), although most are not recreational accessible due to depth.
Critter wise, I'd say Sydney is slightly ahead thanks to the warmer water.
In whale migration season, you can hear the whales singing out while doing a shore dive.
As Michael said, "diving in Sydney is world class", easy accessibility and great diversity!
- Messages
- 7,189
- Reaction score
- 6,231
- # of dives
- 2500 - 4999
For a diver, the best diving is where they live
As I say, the diving where I live is world class, with good accessibility and great diversity most of the time!
As it must be for all the divers the world over
and from a diver that before meandering to different pastures, dived Melbourne for thirty years you
and bought a car instead
as it is Melbourne or wherever in the world you may be
As I say, the diving where I live is world class, with good accessibility and great diversity most of the time!
As it must be for all the divers the world over
and from a diver that before meandering to different pastures, dived Melbourne for thirty years you
and bought a car instead
as it is Melbourne or wherever in the world you may be
justinthedeeps
Contributor
Sydney people can get to Nelson Bay/Point Stephens and Southwest Rocks without too much trouble, which is cool for the nursey sharks
DiveDiversions
Registered
Also Narooma for the Australian and New Zealand seal colonies on Montague Island
And not forgetting Jervis Bay
clownfishsydney
Contributor
I never said it was the best in the world, just world class. Pretty sure no other major city in the world has such good diving within 15 minutes of the city centre, let alone within 30 minutes. Melbourne certainly doesn't nor does Brisbane. Long distances to get to the ocean for both.
As a Sydney-sider I had to chuckle as I read your post; I've done that dive, on that boat! On a good day, Sydney diving can be very enjoyable. On a bad day...well, now you know! I happily dive with SDC every now and then.
Similar threads
