BurBunny
Contributor
Mara, I always enjoy Antigua. The diving experiences aside, I think it's a wonderful island.
Goldenroom, that's tough without knowing what your wife thinks is "cool." I think I'd rate St. Lucia first, Barbados second... Curacao third because I think the town itself is so pretty. After that... for me they all blend a bit. St. Maarten is neat for the two different (and they really are) countries on the same island. I wouldn't put Nassau on the list of topside "cool" sites, though. Aruba's natural bridge is cool, though part of it collapsed this winter
.
None of them would be dogs depending on what you wanted.
Goldenroom, that's tough without knowing what your wife thinks is "cool." I think I'd rate St. Lucia first, Barbados second... Curacao third because I think the town itself is so pretty. After that... for me they all blend a bit. St. Maarten is neat for the two different (and they really are) countries on the same island. I wouldn't put Nassau on the list of topside "cool" sites, though. Aruba's natural bridge is cool, though part of it collapsed this winter

None of them would be dogs depending on what you wanted.