pilot fish:
There are as many bad reasons for diving solo as there are good. It is unwise to dive alone, which is why all the agencies in the World stress buddy diving.
Many of these same agencies, especially the ones that are so against it also try to sell you on the idea that you need alot of cards to be a good diver. Even what I call fluff courses that supposedly count towards Master Diver. I'd like to know how diving with a bugeye mask contributes to you being a "Master Diver". Or taking a course to tell you how to dive off a boat. I have taken specialty courses yes. But I've tried to take ones that would give me the knowledge to do the types of dives I enjoy and do them safely. I began diving solo after rescue. Somewhat out of necessity (due to lack of buddies or buddies I would dive with), but also due to the fact that I enjoy challenges as well as solitude. I don't do photos underwater except when I pick up one of those throw aways on vacation. I have been known however to spend 20 minutes looking for just the right piece of driftwood for my freshwater aquarium. I also have spent just as much time observing a fish that I believe was perch no bigger than my thumb. One of the best local dives I did was a solo night dive. Best vis I ever saw, nobody to screw it up and more kinds of fish as I slowly floated through the water without worrying about who was behind, above, beside, or infront of me. I also solo to build my self rescue and general dive skills. I am on a technical diving path and the type of dives I want to do are deep wrecks. I get a rush out of deep dives and wrecks. Many of these are understood that if you are diving with a buddy they most likely will not pull your butt out of the fire. What they will do is try to give the recovery team the right location of your body. I accept this. I also will not dive with anyone who puts my safety before their own. I dive with alot of students but my safety and well being comes first. If there is an accident I can be of no help if I'm incapacitated.
This is where these agencies are doing a real disservice to many. They put the idea in their heads that as long as you dive with a buddy things will be ok. To rely on your buddy. More emphasis is placed on depending on someone else than on yourself. This is what IMO gets people hurt or worse. Is solo diving for evryone? ABSOLUTELY NOT! It is not for those who are not properly prepared with experience, gear, and training. And I do not mean a solo course. While I would like to have the card just to be able to dive places that will not let you solo without it, I don't believe that solo diving really can be taught. You cannot teach a mindset. You cannot teach total self reliance. You cannot teach confidence in one's gear, experience, or training. That must come from within.
The results of not having these traits and abilities can be tragic in the water or in any truly challenging solo endeavor. Those who do not possess them should stay away from these types of activities. If there is any doubt in your abilities to handle the risks and responsibilities don't. But for those of us who have these skills and abilities and choose to accept the risks, the rewards far outweigh the danger and we should not be subject to criticism for taking on the challenge. For daring to follow our dreams.
"We are raised to honor all the wrong explorers and discoverers- thieves planting flags, murderers carrying crosses. Let us at last praise the colonizers of dreams"
Peter S. Beagle, 14 July 1973