Should I get a BP/W for my girlfriend who hasn't dive before?

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

SangP:
I tried to impress upon her to get a wetsuit for this trip but she said no as only her friends who are really serious about diving have them... getting a rake from a fire coral and other nasties isn't funny but she does not think a wetsuit is necessary yet!


There really is a place where exposure suits are not needed? It's not a fantastic dream?

I would kill to be able to dive here without a wetsuit. Unfortunatly they only thing I would kill is my ability to have children.


If I was in your situation I would wait until after she gets certified and has tried a few different systems before buying one. This way she will be to appreciate the wonders of a BP/W system. ;)
 
Hi guys,

Dochueb a gift cert might not be possible considering that if I'm trying to get her a BP/W the stuff will be from at least 2 dealers and if she does decide to get a back inflate of jacket, I can easily get one here in Singapore.

SeanQ, there are places where not wearing a wetsuit won't be a danger to the crown jewels like Okinawa, parts of SEA and parts of the Maldives. Asia is a great place to relax and enjoy the warm waters. Hawaii sounds great too in fact that's a dream place.

Whatever the case, I'll let her make the decision.

Cheers,

SangP
 
Cash is always nice...
 
SangP:
...I'm deciding weather or not to get a BP/W or a "regular" bc for her as she has never dived before and my LDS keeps trying to sell me a jacket bc. ...I'm not sure about her and I'm worried about the comfort factor as it is ok for me but it may not be the same for her...

There are 2 general principles that it seems like you are overlooking:

1) rent first buy later;

2) let others choose for themselves.

You don't even know if she is going to like scuba, so it makes no sense to buy anything at all. Renting makes the most sense.

After she is certified, and has experience with some different rentals, then it would be a good time for her to make a choice. Not for you to make choices for her.

If she sees you in a plate and wing, and that looks impressive to her, she may become interested in trying one on herself. If she finds it to be uncomfortable, then guess what rule #1 is for gear choice? (hint: comfort and fit.)

I am sure there are women here who can tell you the plate and wing are not a comfort problem. The salient issues are renting first and letting her decide on her gear.

Good luck in the relationship. It looks like you have a lot to learn about the fairer gender.
 
triton94949,

Interestingly long post for a discussion that more or less ended at post 18... hmmmm

SangP



triton94949:
There are 2 general principles that it seems like you are overlooking:

1) rent first buy later;

2) let others choose for themselves.

You don't even know if she is going to like scuba, so it makes no sense to buy anything at all. Renting makes the most sense.

After she is certified, and has experience with some different rentals, then it would be a good time for her to make a choice. Not for you to make choices for her.

If she sees you in a plate and wing, and that looks impressive to her, she may become interested in trying one on herself. If she finds it to be uncomfortable, then guess what rule #1 is for gear choice? (hint: comfort and fit.)

I am sure there are women here who can tell you the plate and wing are not a comfort problem. The salient issues are renting first and letting her decide on her gear.

Good luck in the relationship. It looks like you have a lot to learn about the fairer gender.
 
SangP:
triton94949,

Interestingly long post for a discussion that more or less ended at post 18... hmmmm

SangP

I did not scroll through all the posts, just the first few, and the last few. Those are my thoughts on the issue.

I did not see anyone who reminded you that an uncertified person has no idea whether they will like scuba or not. And I was quite surprised that you are trying to influence a future spouse as though she were your child. And that is why I commented. Like I said, good luck in the relationship.
 
triton94949:
And I was quite surprised that you are trying to influence a future spouse as though she were your child.

Again a rather curious response I wonder where you got the idea from this initial thread?

Regardless, I understand you have good intentions otherwise this thread could get......

SangP
 
SangP:
Again a rather curious response I wonder where you got the idea from this initial thread?

Regardless, I understand you have good intentions otherwise this thread could get......

SangP

I used to date a woman, who was very competitive. She had never been in the ocean, but was a good swimmer all her life. She knew I went to the ocean a lot as a freediver and scuba diver. One weekend, she asked if she could come along on a freediving trip. Strange request, but I agreed. We rented all the gear for her: fins, mask, snorkel, wetsuit, boots, gloves, hood, weight belt. She used my float. She had a blast! It was a wonderful weekend of fun and freediving.

We went again the following weekend as well. That was great too. It turned out that with little or no practive she could already hold her breath as long as me, maybe even longer, because there were times when I would wonder if she was ever going to surface!

She said she enjoyed watching the fishes underwater, how they come up to you, like goldfish in a goldfish bowl, only now you are in the goldfish bowl too, not just looking in. And the purplish coloration of the underwater world was something she said she had never imagined.

There was a sale at the scuba store, so we bought her all of her very own freediving gear. Color was the most important thing to her. I would be careful to check everything to make sure it fit her, but if she did not have it in her favorite color, she would not buy it, so we had to search all over town to find both the perfect fit and her favorite color. Finally we found everything.

After a few months of freediving like this, she wanted to try scuba. She enrolled in a class and we went together. She picked out a back-inflation B/C in her favorite color, and I bought it for her ($600 mistake).

She found the academic portion boring and difficult. She found the pool skills tedious and the pace of the class too fast. For the last weekend at the ocean she had the flu and could not participate in the final dive. After she got well, she had no interest in completing the last dive that she was still missing to get certified. She lost interest in freediving too. Work became really busy and challenging for her, and required a lot more of her time, and so there was never time to get back into scuba.

At no point in the process would I have dared to try to steer her one way or the other. She made her own choices. People are that way. And also, until someone is certified, you have no idea whether they will like scuba or not.

Hope that explains better what I was getting at. That way maybe I can save you $600.
 
Hi triton94949,

As I mentioned earlier, I understand your good intentions and of course I would prefer for her to make her own decision but it's our 5 year together and I wanted to surprise her with her own gear.

It's good to know that people care enough to warn me not to spend on something I'll regret... you guys have been great.

From what you told me about this girl you dated she sounds hot LOL!

I'd already gotten for her some fins and other gear that can be used for snorkling and will let her decide on the scuba gear.

Cheers,

Dillon
 

Back
Top Bottom