You could pack the chamber, but some Christolube would squirt out every time you pressurized the reg, and some air or water would enter when you depressurized. Soon, the little pockets of water would become repositories for salt corrosion.
Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.
Benefits of registering include
I've had a few MK5/10/15/20s that had a similar amount of corrosion in the ambient chamber and have worked fine as well. I can usually get rid of most it with micromesh or silicone carbide paper. But I have had a few that were bad enough to say goodbye to. In rsingler's case, I suspect he's working on a customer's regulator and is hesitant to let it out of the shop with any visible corrosion in the ambient chamber.
Recently I acquired a MK10 with corrosion in the piston head groove, and that one I couldn't get to stop leaking. Thankfully I have a stash of MK10 pistons.
You can't.
It's why I still dive Mk 17's on the diaphragm side, but have switched to Atomic for pistons. Scubapro is just too unresponsive these days.
As for the why, it's because there's no groove in the Mk25 to accept a SPEC boot.