Ruptured Eardrum during Ascent

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

Ed Jackson1

Guest
Messages
291
Reaction score
4
Location
South Tampa
# of dives
Can you rupture your eardrum during ascent? I had trouble during an ascent yesterday and probably ruptured my eardrum. I am puzzled on why it would happend during a very slow ascent from a cave dive. Why could'nt the air escape into the eustachian tube? I did not have any upper respiratory symptoms or congestion prior to the dive. Is it possible to have eustachian tube spasm?
 
I think you are more likely to rupture it on ascent than descent. As the middle ear has very little volume, water pressure exerted from outside into the ear canal would only compress the eardrum inward against the structures of the middle ear and inner ear - causing pain, but not enough stretch to cause rupture.

On ascent, compressed air in the middle ear would expand up to 8 x its initial volume (2x if you were at 33 ft, 4x at 66 ft, and 8x at 100 ft.) this would push outward on the ear drum and causing rupture if it can not be released through the eustachian tube.

Some folks, like myself, have nasal and sinus congestion with decreased body temperature. Apparently some people release histamines from the mast cells at low temperature. This might explain why you were clear at the top, and might have congested at the bottom.
 
here is something from scuba-doc.com....

Good prediving exam. Avoid diving with nasal problems. Good clearing techniques.(See below)
Descend feet first. This not only prevents venous congestion and swelling around the openings to the Eustachian tubes but allows observation of the diving partner, an impossibility during a headfirst descent. A diving problem can occur at any depth, and in most cases a diving partner (qualified) may be able to observe a problem onset and those perhaps reduce the risk to both parties.

Descend on the anchor line. This allows for minute up and down control while clearing and descending.

Don't dive after taking medication that causes nasal congestion. Examples are certain blood pressure and prostate medications. (Hytrin).

Commercial airline passengers sometimes experience barotrauma of the middle ear that requires treatment by a physician. A recent article by Thomas P. Brown, a US Navy physician, explains how such trauma occurs, how it can be prevented, and how it should be treated. The information can be interpolated to apply to divers--just reverse the sequence.

During aircraft ascent, ambient pressure decreases slowly, causing the tympanic membrane to bulge outward. When the pressure differential reaches 15 mm Hg -- approximately every 122 m (400 ft) in increased altitude -- the properly functioning eustachian tube vents the positive pressure. On descent, the ambient pressure increases; the tympanic membrane bulges inward, and the eustachian tube resists the positive inward flow. Passengers experience discomfort when the differential reaches 60 mm Hg. At 90 mm Hg, the eustachian tube locks up, preventing the equalization of pressure by whatever means. A 100- to 500-mm Hg differential causes the tympanic membrane to rupture, relieving the pain but often resulting in vomiting, loss of hearing, dizziness, and vertigo.

During barotrauma, the tympanic membrane becomes distorted with respect to color, shape and integrity. As barotrauma progresses, the tympanic membrane mucosa becomes edematous, there is hemorrhaging, and a transudate forms in the middle ear. The tympanic membrane sometimes ruptures because of weakness of the tympanic membrane, inadequate transudate or hematoma formation, or too rapid a change in pressure.

The most effective means of combating middle ear block is to avoid flying while experiencing upper respiratory tract infection. Passengers should yawn, chew, or swallow -- activities that open the eustachian tube momentarily and allow for pressure equalization. Valsalva's maneuver, taking a small breath, holding the nose, and attempting to force air through the closed nostrils, is especially effective in equalizing pressure during descent. If flying in a small plane with few passengers, the pilot may be asked to reascend.

One hour before takeoff and again 30 minutes before, two puffs of oxymetazoline hydrochloride will constrict the arterioles of the nasal mucosa, permitting the eustachian tube to function efficiently. Oral decongestants (e.g., pseudoephedrine and phenylpropanolamine), which affect areas that sprays don't reach, may be initiated 1 or 2 days before a flight. Newer antihistamines without sedating effects may also be effective. Severe or unremitting earblock may be treated by a physician using a Politzer bag. With the patient seated, one nostril is occluded and the flange of the bag is inserted into the other nostril. While the patient rapidly repeats the letter K or takes small sips of water, the bulb is compressed. The Politzer bag is effective in clearing ear block in 50% of cases. If the patient has excruciating pain or still has earblock after one week of the treatments described, myringotomy may be required.

(Brown T. Postgrad Med. 1994; 96: 135-142.)
 
Thanks. I'm going to an ENT tomorrow. Yesterday, I had a clogged sensation and trouble hearing. I saw some blood in my ear canal today, but my hearing is back to normal and I do not have the stuffy feeling anymore. I'm still not sure it ruptured, but I definitely had some barotrauma. At least my hearing is better. I was worried about possible permanent damage.
 
I had the same situation, one day of diving a had that in my right ear, then a few weeks later i went diving and it happend in the left ear, its weird because, both times it happend at the end of the dive in about 15 feet of water on the way up. i felt pressure and attempted to equalize, then i hear a slight squeal followed by vertigo. then pain at the end of the day for a while. the first time was much worse, the pain was pretty rough for about a day, followed by about 2 weeks of the "plugged ear" feeling. the second time wasnt as bad, the pain was only mild for about 3 hrs, and the plugged ear feeling only lasted 3 or 4 days. but all in all it sucked.
 
Scubapat:
I had the same situation, one day of diving a had that in my right ear, then a few weeks later i went diving and it happend in the left ear, its weird because, both times it happend at the end of the dive in about 15 feet of water on the way up. i felt pressure and attempted to equalize, then i hear a slight squeal followed by vertigo. then pain at the end of the day for a while. the first time was much worse, the pain was pretty rough for about a day, followed by about 2 weeks of the "plugged ear" feeling. the second time wasnt as bad, the pain was only mild for about 3 hrs, and the plugged ear feeling only lasted 3 or 4 days. but all in all it sucked.


I'm still not sure if I ruptured my eardrum or not. The ENT saw a hematoma in my external canal but he could not visualize the entire drum. He lanced the hematoma and told me to come back in a week. I never had any sensation of vertigo and was not able to feel air going through my eardrum when I blow my nose. Did you have any of these symptoms or did you ever see a ENT to find out if you had a rupture?
 
the symtoms i got were a brief rushing sound followed by disorientation/dizzyness for a second. for a brief time about a week later i could feel air coming through my ear when i breathed, but i have felt that feeling before after a few miles of biking, so im assuming that was unrelated. from what i have been reading it seems like our similar situations maybe a block of some sort, but i could be wrong. and no i did not see and emt cuz the symtoms went away, and im a big baby when it comes to going to the doctor :D
 
What is more scary to me than a rupture of the eardrum, which is reversible, is injury to the innerear.

I would not know how to diagnose it except for the possibility of tinnitus, dizziness or vertigo, and fluid or blood in the middle ear. I think this is the undiagnosed form of ear barotrauma that has resulted in much of the hearing loss of divers.

Per scubadoc.com, it is defined as followed:

Rupture of the Round Window
A rupture of the round or oval window of the inner ear, also called a perilymph fistula, is never painful. This leaves an opening so that inner ear fluid escapes and can cause permanent hearing loss. This is caused by forcing the blocked ear open with too much pressure. Therefore always be gentle. If you can't clear, go up 5 feet and try again.
 
I feel that of the most neglected risk of diving is hearing loss. My PADI training 13 years ago barely mentioned the permanent risk of an ear squeeze.

Despite my reservation against point blank recommendation for routine use of psudofed or any otc or prescription drugs prior to a dive, I think the diving community should do more studies into the benefits of using safe otc drugs routinely during recreational diving.

My proposal would be, if possible, and avoiding the risk of lawsuits, randomly divide 5 or 5 groups of divers:

1. One using placebo nose spray and placebo pill.

2. One using sudafed alone (assuming they have no cardiac risk factors) and placebo nose spray.

3. One using a non-drowsy antihistamine like claritin or allegra, and placebo nose spray.

4. One using either the antihistamine and Afrin like nosespray.

5. One using Afrin nasal spray and a placebo.

With the same group of divers followed over a year (case controlled study), and randomly assigned to each of these 5 to 6 groups, one can determine the frequency of ear symptoms.

My gut feeling is - any of the medications will decrease the incidence of ear barotrauma.

However, again, I would reiterate, that no diving shop, diving instructors, diving organisation, or physician should point blank make a non-conditional recommendation for any over the counter or Rx drug for use in scuba divers... Due to the risk of law suits.

But, isn't it about time for us to look into a preventable long term risk of diving??
 
That would be an interesting study, but I do worry about taking pseudophed with technical diving when 100 percent O2 is used at the deco stop. Some people believe that it could lower the seizure threshold.
 
https://www.shearwater.com/products/teric/

Back
Top Bottom