Trip Report ROATAN 2024 - TRIP REPORT, PIX, & VIDEO LINKS

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

Thumbs up on diving with John Carter! I first met John in the late 1980s when he was working on Grand Cayman as a DM. I learned so much about macro diving from him .Ended up having countless shore diving adventures together and becoming great friends over the years. You were lucky to have him back at AKR, I tried to convince him to stay on GC after a short revisit this past winter!

Cindy
 
How would you compare Roatan to Cozumel or curaçao diving/reef health wise? I’m debating between here and those places or Bonaire or Caymans for February? Want the best diving, best reef. LOVE you found so many seahorses. That might be worth it enough right there!
 
How would you compare Roatan to Cozumel or curaçao diving/reef health wise?
I've never dove Curacao and haven't been to Cozumel since 2005. So I don't think I can offer you a comparison that would be accurate.
 
What photo equipment were you using? Any experience with Marble Hill Resort? Considering going in Feb 2025.
 
Do you know if the dining hall is fully enclosed, ie, glassed in, or is open to fresh air? I'm one of those few remaining souls who doesn't like to eat in a crowded place that's fully enclosed to avoid Covid.
 
Thanks for the detailed report. I really should have written one after my trip earlier in the year. I was very positively impressed with AKR and the dive operation overall. Things ran smoothly and they made it easy for those who wanted or needed to skip some dives but not miss others. Just once (and partly my fault) they forgot to load the tank for my second dive. They were horrified to see me carrying it myself :).

One thing that several of us were annoyed by was the tendency of the dive guides to harass the wildlife. Of course there's always a judgement call between pointing out things for your customers and not going too far. In my opinion, forcing garden eels out of the sand by poking them with a rod is going too far. Surrounding a cornered octopus with a dozen divers and their lights and flashes for over 15 minutes on a night dive is egregious. My buddy and I just stayed nearby and looked at other things, in agreement even though it was our first dive together.

We heard claims that other parts of the area had less coral damage, but I don't think I can go back. I have seen coral bleaching and other damage many times, but this was the first dive trip when I have been actively sad underwater. You could see the many coral-built structures and imagine what they were just a few years ago.
 
Thanks for the detailed report. I really should have written one after my trip earlier in the year. I was very positively impressed with AKR and the dive operation overall. Things ran smoothly and they made it easy for those who wanted or needed to skip some dives but not miss others. Just once (and partly my fault) they forgot to load the tank for my second dive. They were horrified to see me carrying it myself :).

One thing that several of us were annoyed by was the tendency of the dive guides to harass the wildlife. Of course there's always a judgement call between pointing out things for your customers and not going too far. In my opinion, forcing garden eels out of the sand by poking them with a rod is going too far. Surrounding a cornered octopus with a dozen divers and their lights and flashes for over 15 minutes on a night dive is egregious. My buddy and I just stayed nearby and looked at other things, in agreement even though it was our first dive together.

We heard claims that other parts of the area had less coral damage, but I don't think I can go back. I have seen coral bleaching and other damage many times, but this was the first dive trip when I have been actively sad underwater. You could see the many coral-built structures and imagine what they were just a few years ago.
Agreed about the coral bleaching. It is a Caribbean wide issue, with water temps extremely high. We started seeing it years ago in Bonaire. Now its everywhere. Better dive it while you can...may get worse.
 

Back
Top Bottom