I just got back from AC and don't think you can go wrong with many of the choices. The beach locations tend to be more expensive than those restaurants on Pescador/Middle Street. My favorite place was Elvi's. Following close were Licks (excellent breakfast and caye lime pie), Estelle's (only open breakfast & lunch and cash only), Blue Water, and Wild Mango. Again, hard to go wrong and choice is going to be more about how much time you have between/before dives and how much you want to spend.
Many of the restaurants are closed at least one day a week, so if you want to try something specific, be sure to check. The usual day to be closed was Sunday, though some are closed Monday or Tuesday. An increasing number take credit cards, but there are still many of the smaller more local places that are cash only.
Many of the restaurants are closed at least one day a week, so if you want to try something specific, be sure to check. The usual day to be closed was Sunday, though some are closed Monday or Tuesday. An increasing number take credit cards, but there are still many of the smaller more local places that are cash only.