After years of experience and experimentation I'm of the opinion a bungee isn't necessary, and fixing the basics is the place to start. You're bascially proving my point with your photos.
What you're showing me in the first photos are that that person's harness and rigging is absolutely nowhere near correctly setup. Sure, throw a bungee on it and problem solved. I agree it works and it does work well. But it is far from necessary and is potentially masking the underlying problem. There are several things that could be done to fix what's in the before photos.
You're completely correct and we're in no way different.
This is the Solo Diving forum. In here people should know how to rig stages and will be familiar with bringing redundant gas supplies.
I was trying to show how (heavy) cylinders dangle when they're clipped on using the bog-standard clipping method, to the chest D-ring and the LH waist D-ring. It's me in both pics.
With a dangly stage, especially a decompression stage with 50% or 80% oxygen, the stage will do a pendulum trick: as you fin forwards it moves back, absorbing some of your finning energy, then it swings forwards effectively pushing you backwards. The worst thing with a dangly stage is if it's got some helium in the mix for a bottom stage or it is empty, the base of the stage points up to the sky; dangerous in overheads.
Fixing a dangly stage can be tricky as, by definition, your stage clips act like levers if they're both pointing up. Adjusting the length of the stage rigging kit can help, but then it can be a real pig to clip the stage on and off. Bungees prevent this by putting some tension on the lower clip, keeping the bottom of the stage in check and ensuring it doesn't pendulum nor stick upwards.
Bungees need a bit of messing around with to adjust correctly. Too little tension means the stage moves around too much. If the bungee's too tight then it's a pig to pull on and it's uncomfortable.
My personal usage of bungees has evolved over the years. I've no idea of other people's bungee implementations, this is Solo diving!
I use two chest D-rings on the harness, one in the "normal" above the nipple-level position (used for clipping stuff on and off; torches, double enders, etc.) and another D-ring a couple of inches below that which is used for clipping stage nose clips on. This allows more space for the stage to move under my armpit with the clip in situ.
Aside: you need nose clips on stages to move the things around, such as carrying them. Wearing your harness, lean forwards and clip the stage on. Then stand up. Sidemount with no nose clip is a right pain to walk around with the stages on.
I clip the bottom stage clip to my waist belt with a sidewards-pointing D-ring, which moves the clipping point to your hip, not waist.
The bungees are left
unclipped on the boat before jumping, or walking into water. Once in (generally when down the shot line), I'll check everything over and hook on the bungees, pushing the stages back under my armpits.
When ascending to the boat, I'll unclip the bungees before the final ascent so the stages dangle forwards again. This makes it much easier if anyone's kind enough to remove your stages when you get back on the boat.
One day I'll take some photos of this whole thing! I did describe it in the rebreather section:
Sidemounting Bailouts With the modifications to the harness a pair of sidemount bungee loops were added. Alternative sidemounting methods include the Dive Rite bungee + ring system plus many others. The point of this is to get the bailouts under control so they're pulled back under the...
scubaboard.com