Yes, but sometimes miracle happensPelagics are pretty rare in PG unfortunately.
Last year -May we saw the small (about 5-6 m) whale shark on the house reef of Oasis resort on Pangalao. I was with 2 students and they did there first dive in Open Water The rest of the group (certified divers) dive that day on Balicasag
It was my 6-th trip to Panglao and first time whale shark there....